Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York.
Department of Dermatology, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York.
JAMA Dermatol. 2022 Oct 1;158(10):1175-1182. doi: 10.1001/jamadermatol.2022.3628.
Nonmelanoma skin cancers (NMSCs) are primarily diagnosed through paraffin section histologic analysis of skin biopsy specimens that requires days to weeks before a formal diagnosis is reported. Two-photon fluorescence microscopy (TPFM) has the potential for point-of-care diagnosis of NMSC and other dermatologic conditions, which could enable same-visit diagnosis and treatment.
To demonstrate that TPFM imaging of NMSC can occur within minutes of obtaining biopsies and provide similar histological features to those of conventional histology and evaluate TPFM diagnostic performance with respect to conventional histology.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This comparative effectiveness pilot study examined 29 freshly excised biopsies from confirmed NMSC lesions in patients presenting for treatment. Biopsies underwent imaging immediately with TPFM on site at Rochester Dermatologic Surgery (Victor, New York) between October 2019 and August 2021. The imaged biopsies were subsequently submitted for paraffin histology to produce coregistered images. Twelve of these coregistered image pairs (41.4%) were used as a training set. Fifteen (51.7%) were used in a masked evaluation by a board-certified dermatopathologist. Two (6.9%) were excluded from the study before evaluation because they could not be coregistered.
Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of TPFM for NMSC biopsies were evaluated compared with conventional histology.
Fourteen of the 15 biopsy specimens (93.3%) in the evaluation set were identically diagnosed with TPFM and paraffin histology. The TPFM had 100% sensitivity (95% CI, 48%-100%), 100% specificity (95% CI, 69%-100%), and 100% accuracy (95% CI, 78%-100%) for basal cell carcinoma diagnosis. For squamous cell carcinoma diagnosis, TPFM had 89% sensitivity (95% CI, 52%-100), 100% specificity (95% CI, 54%-100%), and 93% accuracy (95% CI, 68%-100%). For overall NMSC diagnosis, TPFM had a 93% sensitivity (95% CI, 66%-100%), 100% specificity (95% CI, 3%-100%), and 93% accuracy (95% CI, 68%-100%). Examination of the 1 discordant pair revealed mismatched imaging planes as the source of error.
The results of this comparative effectiveness pilot study suggest that TPFM captures histological characteristics of NMSC that are present in conventional histology, which reveals its potential as a rapid, point-of-care diagnostic alternative that does not need extensive sample preparation or retraining for image evaluation. Further validation of TPFM imaging performed for a larger cohort is needed to fully evaluate its diagnostic accuracy and potential effect within the field.
非黑色素瘤皮肤癌(NMSC)主要通过皮肤活检标本的石蜡切片组织学分析进行诊断,在正式报告诊断之前需要数天到数周的时间。双光子荧光显微镜(TPFM)具有在获得活检后几分钟内进行 NMSC 及其他皮肤病诊断的潜力,这可以实现同一次就诊的诊断和治疗。
证明 NMSC 的 TPFM 成像可以在获得活检后的几分钟内进行,并提供与传统组织学相似的组织学特征,并评估 TPFM 相对于传统组织学的诊断性能。
设计、地点和参与者:这项比较有效性试点研究检查了 29 例来自接受治疗的确诊 NMSC 病变患者的新鲜切除活检。在 2019 年 10 月至 2021 年 8 月期间,在罗切斯特皮肤病外科学(纽约州维克多)现场使用 TPFM 立即对活检进行成像。随后将成像的活检进行石蜡组织学处理以产生配准图像。这些配准图像对中有 12 对(41.4%)被用作训练集。15 对(51.7%)由经过认证的皮肤科病理学家进行了盲法评估。由于无法配准,研究中有 2 对(6.9%)在评估前被排除在外。
与传统组织学相比,评估了 TPFM 对 NMSC 活检的敏感性、特异性和准确性。
在评估集中的 15 个活检标本中有 14 个(93.3%)与 TPFM 和石蜡组织学完全一致。TPFM 对基底细胞癌诊断的敏感性为 100%(95%CI,48%-100%)、特异性为 100%(95%CI,69%-100%)和准确性为 100%(95%CI,78%-100%)。鳞状细胞癌诊断时,TPFM 的敏感性为 89%(95%CI,52%-100),特异性为 100%(95%CI,54%-100%),准确性为 93%(95%CI,68%-100%)。对于整体 NMSC 诊断,TPFM 的敏感性为 93%(95%CI,66%-100%)、特异性为 100%(95%CI,3%-100%)和准确性为 93%(95%CI,68%-100%)。对 1 个不一致的对进行检查发现,成像平面不匹配是错误的来源。
这项比较有效性试点研究的结果表明,TPFM 捕获了 NMSC 的组织学特征,这些特征存在于传统组织学中,这揭示了其作为一种快速、即时的护理点诊断替代方案的潜力,而无需广泛的样本制备或重新培训进行图像评估。需要对更大的队列进行进一步的 TPFM 成像验证,以充分评估其诊断准确性和在该领域的潜在影响。