Department of Pathology, Brigham and Women's Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Weill Cornell Medicine and New York Presbyterian Hospital, New York, NY, USA.
Mod Pathol. 2022 Dec;35(12):1784-1790. doi: 10.1038/s41379-022-01153-0. Epub 2022 Sep 7.
Compared to other medical specialties, pathology has a significant number of women in the academic workforce (43%). Gender disparities, particularly those disadvantaging women, are a reality in academic medicine with documented inequalities in salary, leadership opportunities, and faculty promotion. One important element of academic advancement is the recognition obtained when serving as editor or main author of reference textbooks. We aimed to document the gender distribution of editors/authors in anatomic pathology by surveying 205 subspecialty publications over a 20-year period. Gender of each editor/author was recorded after surveying their institutional or other professional biographies. When biography was non-contributory, gender was extracted from the National Provider Identifier Database. A total of 462 editors/authors were identified: 275 (59.5%) men and 187 (40.5%) women. This distribution was similar to the 2015 (39% women) and 2019 (43.4% women) Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) benchmark for US academic pathologists. The gender distribution in each of the main anatomic pathology subspecialties was estimated by surveying the websites of 20 North American academic pathology departments (totaling 1893 listed individuals). Compared to this benchmark, some subspecialties had more men in editor/author roles than their representation in academic departments including Dermatopathology (observed vs expected difference, ∆ = 41.3%), Genitourinary Pathology (∆ = 29.4%), Renal & Transplant Pathology (∆ = 22.4%) and Head & Neck Pathology (∆ = 21.6%). Other subspecialties had more women in editor/author roles than their representation in academic departments including Molecular Pathology (∆ = 31.4%), Gastrointestinal Pathology (∆ = 21.4%), and Bone & Soft Tissue Pathology (∆ = 19.4%). Editors/authors of multiple (>1) publications were frequent and skewed gender representation in most specialties. The overall gender distribution of editor/author roles is similar to that of the US pathology workforce. However, significant disparities exist in certain subspecialties affecting both women and men. This landscape can guide efforts by editors, publishers, and academic institutions to bring equity to the academic field by providing fair editorial and authorship opportunities to academic pathologists.
与其他医学专业相比,病理学领域的学术劳动力中女性比例较高(占 43%)。性别差异,尤其是对女性不利的性别差异,在学术医学中是一个现实,薪酬、领导机会和教师晋升方面存在着有据可查的不平等。学术进步的一个重要因素是担任参考教科书编辑或主要作者所获得的认可。我们旨在通过调查 20 年来 205 种亚专业出版物,记录解剖病理学编辑/作者的性别分布。在调查了他们的机构或其他专业传记后,记录了每位编辑/作者的性别。当传记没有贡献时,从国家提供者标识符数据库中提取性别。总共确定了 462 名编辑/作者:275 名(59.5%)男性和 187 名(40.5%)女性。这一分布与 2015 年(女性占 39%)和 2019 年(女性占 43.4%)美国医学协会(AAMC)美国学术病理学家的基准相似。通过调查北美 20 个学术病理学系的网站(总计列出了 1893 名个人),估计了每个主要解剖病理学亚专业的性别分布。与该基准相比,一些亚专业中编辑/作者的男性比例高于学术部门的比例,包括皮肤病理学(观察到的差异与预期差异,∆=41.3%)、泌尿生殖系统病理学(∆=29.4%)、肾脏和移植病理学(∆=22.4%)和头颈部病理学(∆=21.6%)。其他亚专业中编辑/作者的女性比例高于学术部门,包括分子病理学(∆=31.4%)、胃肠病理学(∆=21.4%)和骨与软组织病理学(∆=19.4%)。多个(>1)出版物的编辑/作者经常出现,并且大多数专业的性别代表性存在偏差。编辑/作者角色的总体性别分布与美国病理学劳动力相似。然而,某些亚专业存在显著的性别差异,影响到男女两性。这种情况可以指导编辑、出版商和学术机构的努力,通过为学术病理学家提供公平的编辑和作者机会,为学术领域带来公平。