Radiation Oncology, Department of Radiotherapy, Hospital "A. Perrino", ASL Brindisi, 72100 Brindisi, Italy.
Institute for Research on Population and Social Policies, National Research Council, 72100 Brindisi, Italy.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Aug 30;19(17):10800. doi: 10.3390/ijerph191710800.
This review systematically summarizes the evidence on the economic impact of magnetic resonance image-guided RT (MRIgRT).
We systematically searched INAHTA, MEDLINE, and Scopus up to March 2022 to retrieve health economic studies. Relevant data were extracted on study type, model inputs, modeling methods and economic results.
Five studies were included. Two studies performed a full economic assessment to compare the cost-effectiveness of MRIgRT with other forms of image-guided radiation therapy. One study performed a cost minimization analysis and two studies performed an activity-based costing, all comparing MRIgRT with X-ray computed tomography image-guided radiation therapy (CTIgRT). Prostate cancer was the target condition in four studies and hepatocellular carcinoma in one. Considering the studies with a full economic assessment, MR-guided stereotactic body radiation therapy was found to be cost effective with respect to CTIgRT or conventional or moderate hypofractionated RT, even with a low reduction in toxicity. Conversely, a greater reduction in toxicity is required to compete with extreme hypofractionated RT without MR guidance.
This review highlights the great potential of MRIgRT but also the need for further evidence, especially for late toxicity, whose reduction is expected to be the real added value of this technology.
本综述系统总结了磁共振影像引导放射治疗(MRIgRT)的经济影响证据。
我们系统地检索了 INAHTA、MEDLINE 和 Scopus,截至 2022 年 3 月,以检索关于健康经济学研究的文献。提取了研究类型、模型输入、建模方法和经济结果的相关数据。
纳入了 5 项研究。其中 2 项研究进行了全面的经济评估,以比较 MRIgRT 与其他形式的图像引导放射治疗的成本效益。1 项研究进行了成本最小化分析,2 项研究进行了基于活动的成本核算,均比较了 MRIgRT 与 X 射线计算机断层扫描图像引导放射治疗(CTIgRT)。4 项研究的目标条件为前列腺癌,1 项为肝细胞癌。考虑到进行全面经济评估的研究,MR 引导立体定向体部放射治疗与 C TigRT 或常规或中度适形分割放射治疗相比具有成本效益,即使毒性降低幅度较小。相反,如果没有磁共振引导,要与极端适形分割放射治疗竞争,则需要更大程度地降低毒性。
本综述强调了 MRIgRT 的巨大潜力,但也需要更多证据,特别是关于晚期毒性的证据,预计这将是该技术的真正附加值。