Britt Katherine Carroll, Kwak Jung, Acton Gayle, Richards Kathy C, Hamilton Jill, Radhakrishnan Kavita
School of Nursing The University of Texas at Austin Austin Texas USA.
Nell Hodgson Woodruff School of Nursing Emory University Atlanta Georgia USA.
Alzheimers Dement (N Y). 2022 Sep 1;8(1):e12352. doi: 10.1002/trc2.12352. eCollection 2022.
Literature on the association of religion and spirituality (R/S) and health is growing. However, it is unclear how R/S affects outcomes and is assessed in persons with dementia (PWDs). In this integrative review, we evaluate published R/S measures and synthesize R/S findings for PWDs.
We searched five databases (ATLA Religion, CINAHL, PsychInfo, PubMed, SocIndex) and identified 14 of 1043 studies for review. We assess the studies' information, quality, measures, and results.
We identified 17 measures for R/S: six were adapted for use with PWDs and only two were validated for PWDs; most studies reported only measures' reliability, with Cronbach's alpha. The studies' findings support significant positive associations between R/S and cognitive function and negative associations between R/S and depression and behavioral expressions.
The two validated scales indicated acceptable validity with overall good reliability. Nevertheless, diverse samples and rigorous study designs are needed to improve R/S measures and to examine associations over time for PWDs.
Few scales for measuring religion and spirituality (R/S) have been validated in persons with dementia (PWD); additional testing is needed.Most R/S measures only reported scale reliability with Cronbach's alpha.Studies supported positive associations between R/S and health yet few studies exist. conducted.Only one spiritual intervention, spiritual reminiscence, was found for PWD.More rigorous R/S studies are needed to examine health outcomes in dementia.
关于宗教与精神信仰(R/S)和健康之间关联的文献不断增加。然而,尚不清楚R/S如何影响结果以及在痴呆症患者(PWD)中是如何评估的。在这项综合综述中,我们评估已发表的R/S测量方法,并综合PWD的R/S研究结果。
我们检索了五个数据库(ATLA宗教、护理学与健康领域数据库、心理学文摘数据库、医学期刊数据库、社会科学索引),从1043项研究中确定了14项进行综述。我们评估这些研究的信息、质量、测量方法和结果。
我们确定了17种R/S测量方法:其中六种适用于PWD,只有两种在PWD中得到验证;大多数研究仅报告了测量方法的信度,采用的是克朗巴哈系数。研究结果支持R/S与认知功能之间存在显著正相关,以及R/S与抑郁和行为表现之间存在负相关。
这两种经过验证的量表显示出可接受的效度和总体良好的信度。然而,需要不同的样本和严谨的研究设计来改进R/S测量方法,并随着时间推移研究PWD的关联情况。
在痴呆症患者(PWD)中,很少有测量宗教与精神信仰(R/S)的量表得到验证,需要进一步测试。大多数R/S测量方法仅报告了采用克朗巴哈系数的量表信度。研究支持R/S与健康之间存在正相关,但相关研究较少。仅发现一种针对PWD的精神干预措施,即精神回忆。需要更严谨的R/S研究来检查痴呆症患者的健康结果。