Song Bokhyun, Kim Hyo Yeol, Jung Yong Gi, Baek Chung-Hwan, Chung Man Ki, Hong Sang Duk
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Samsung Medical Center, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Clin Exp Otorhinolaryngol. 2022 Nov;15(4):354-363. doi: 10.21053/ceo.2022.00465. Epub 2022 Aug 30.
Post-radiation nasopharyngeal necrosis (PRNN) is a serious complication that severely impacts the quality of life and survival of nasopharyngeal carcinoma patients. Endoscopic debridement is considered the first-line treatment for PRNN. This study aimed to analyze clinical outcomes, focusing on the mucosal resurfacing status and the effectiveness of salvage operations.
Twenty-seven patients who underwent endoscopic debridement were retrospectively analyzed. The patients were divided into two groups according to the initial surgical modality: debridement with a nasoseptal flap (NSF; n=21) and debridement only (no NSF; n=6). Clinical features, postoperative mucosal status, internal carotid artery (ICA) rupture, survival, and final mucosal status were evaluated. The NSF group was categorized according to flap viability to analyze risk factors for flap failure.
Regardless of the initial modality, most patients experienced symptom improvement (96.0% for headache and 100% for foul odor); however, complete cranial nerve palsy did not improve in any patients. In the NSF group, complete healing was observed in 66.7%, while all patients in the no-NSF group underwent salvage surgery because none maintained complete healing. In the NSF group, 19.0% of patients required salvage surgery. After the last operation, favorable symptom improvement was noted (100% for headache and 90.0% for foul odor), and 77.8% had completely healed mucosa, whereas only 14.8% and 7.4% had partial healing and persistent necrotic mucosal status. The necrotic or uncovered NSF subgroup showed statistically non-significant tendencies for old age, advanced necrosis stage, advanced T stage, ICA involvement, high frequency and dose of radiation therapy, diabetes mellitus, and underlying comorbidities. Two ICA ruptures and three deaths occurred.
Resurfacing the nasopharynx with NSF after endoscopic debridement showed better outcomes than debridement only for PRNN treatment. Despite initial NSF failure, additional resurfacing reconstructive surgery offers advantages in symptom mitigation, quality of life, and survival.
放疗后鼻咽坏死(PRNN)是一种严重并发症,严重影响鼻咽癌患者的生活质量和生存率。内镜清创术被认为是PRNN的一线治疗方法。本研究旨在分析临床结果,重点关注黏膜修复状态和挽救手术的有效性。
回顾性分析27例行内镜清创术的患者。根据初始手术方式将患者分为两组:带鼻中隔瓣清创术(NSF;n = 21)和单纯清创术(无NSF;n = 6)。评估临床特征、术后黏膜状态、颈内动脉(ICA)破裂情况、生存率和最终黏膜状态。NSF组根据皮瓣活力进行分类,以分析皮瓣失败的危险因素。
无论初始手术方式如何,大多数患者症状均有改善(头痛改善率为96.0%,恶臭改善率为100%);然而,所有患者的完全性脑神经麻痹均未改善。在NSF组中,66.7%观察到完全愈合,而无NSF组的所有患者均接受了挽救手术,因为没有患者维持完全愈合。在NSF组中,19.0%的患者需要挽救手术。最后一次手术后,症状得到良好改善(头痛改善率为100%,恶臭改善率为90.0%),77.8%的患者黏膜完全愈合,而仅有14.8%和7.4%的患者部分愈合和持续坏死性黏膜状态。坏死或未覆盖的NSF亚组在年龄较大、坏死分期较晚、T分期较晚、ICA受累、放疗频率和剂量较高、糖尿病和基础合并症方面显示出统计学上无显著差异的趋势。发生了2例ICA破裂和3例死亡。
内镜清创术后用NSF修复鼻咽比单纯清创术治疗PRNN的效果更好。尽管初始NSF失败,但额外的修复重建手术在缓解症状、提高生活质量和生存率方面具有优势。