Child Oriented Mental health Intervention Centre (COMIC), Leeds & York Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, York, United Kingdom.
School of Health and Related Research (ScHARR), University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2022 Sep 15;17(9):e0274424. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0274424. eCollection 2022.
Between 2015 and 2020 the Alleviating Specific Phobias Experienced by Children Trial (ASPECT) was conducted in the UK to examine the non-inferiority of One-Session Treatment in comparison to Cognitive Behavioural Therapy based interventions for children and young people with specific phobias. A nested qualitative evaluation was conducted as part of this trial to examine the acceptability of One-Session Treatment. Qualitative interviews were conducted with children and young people taking part in the trial, their parents/guardians, and clinicians delivering the intervention, about their experiences and the acceptability of One Session Treatment. Interviews were digitally recorded and transcribed verbatim. Analysis followed a qualitative framework approach, a widely used method of analysing primary qualitative data pertaining to healthcare practices with policy relevance. Stakeholder groups found One Session Treatment to be an acceptable intervention and barriers and facilitators for its implementation into services were also identified. Potential barriers included challenges to patient flow and treatment scepticism, whilst facilitators included adopting a child-centred approach, child readiness and suitability, opportunity for increased momentum, parental support and involvement, and proximal and distal gains. For One Session Treatment's successful implementation into services, consideration of these barriers is needed and suitability guidance for its use in this population should be developed. Further research exploring children and young people's experiences of receiving Cognitive Behavioural Therapy and its acceptability in comparison to One Session Treatment would be welcomed.
2015 年至 2020 年,英国开展了缓解儿童特定恐惧症试验(ASPECT),旨在检验单次治疗与基于认知行为疗法的干预措施对患有特定恐惧症的儿童和青少年的非劣效性。作为该试验的一部分,进行了一项嵌套式定性评估,以检验单次治疗的可接受性。对参与试验的儿童和青少年、他们的父母/监护人以及提供干预措施的临床医生进行了定性访谈,了解他们对单次治疗的体验和可接受性。访谈进行了数字录音,并逐字记录。分析遵循定性框架方法,这是一种广泛用于分析与具有政策相关性的医疗保健实践相关的主要定性数据的方法。利益相关者群体认为单次治疗是一种可接受的干预措施,并且还确定了将其实施到服务中的障碍和促进因素。潜在障碍包括患者流程和治疗怀疑方面的挑战,而促进因素包括采用以儿童为中心的方法、儿童准备情况和适用性、增加动力的机会、父母的支持和参与以及近端和远端收益。为了将单次治疗成功地实施到服务中,需要考虑这些障碍,并应制定针对该人群使用单次治疗的适用性指南。欢迎进一步研究探索儿童和青少年接受认知行为疗法的体验及其与单次治疗的可接受性。