Mekonnen Dessie Ayalew, Roets Lizeth
Department of Health Studies, College of Human Sciences, University of South Africa, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Department of Health Studies, College of Human Sciences, University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa.
HIV AIDS (Auckl). 2022 Sep 15;14:423-435. doi: 10.2147/HIV.S369429. eCollection 2022.
The World Health Organization recommends that family planning be integrated in HIV services, to improve service offering and uptake; stakeholder involvement is crucial. The purpose of this manuscript is to share the utilization of nominal group technique (NGT) and multiple group analysis as a vehicle to ensure stakeholder involvement in the development of a strategic action plan to improve the implementation of integrated services in Ethiopia.
A qualitative research design, employing a NGT, was applied as data-gathering method to develop a strategic action plan for facilitating the integration of family planning and HIV services. NGT was used to ensure the equal involvement of stakeholders in the development thereof. Twenty-four programme managers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia - experts in family planning and HIV/AIDS programmes, working in 10 sub-city health departments - participated in the nominal groups to identify the strategies to be included in an action plan development to facilitate integrated services.
The first nominal group's participants identified 12 themes, derived from the 21 categories generated from 34 individual ideas. The second group identified nine themes, from 16 categories, generated from 30 individually ideas. A multiple group analysis utilizing the findings from both groups revealed the top five most important themes (leadership and management, capacity building, implementing policies and guidelines, advocacy/awareness and infrastructure) that were selected to be included in a strategic action plan to integrated family planning and HIV services in Ethiopia.
The strategic action plan developed by the researcher who took into account the findings from the multiple group analysis was validated in a face-to-face validation meeting by all the relevant stakeholder's participation. Stakeholder involvement, utilizing different nominal groups and conducting multiple nominal group analysis ensured ownership of the strategic action plan as those involved in the development, will be the individuals to implement in Ethiopia.
世界卫生组织建议将计划生育纳入艾滋病服务中,以改善服务提供和接受情况;利益相关者的参与至关重要。本文的目的是分享名义小组技术(NGT)和多组分析的应用,以此作为一种手段,确保利益相关者参与制定一项战略行动计划,以改善埃塞俄比亚综合服务的实施情况。
采用定性研究设计,运用名义小组技术作为数据收集方法,以制定一项促进计划生育与艾滋病服务整合的战略行动计划。名义小组技术用于确保利益相关者在制定过程中的平等参与。埃塞俄比亚亚的斯亚贝巴的24名项目经理——计划生育和艾滋病项目专家,在10个分区卫生部门工作——参与了名义小组,以确定纳入行动计划制定的战略,以促进综合服务。
第一个名义小组的参与者从34个个人想法产生的21个类别中确定了12个主题。第二个小组从30个个人想法产生的16个类别中确定了9个主题。利用两组结果进行的多组分析揭示了最重要的五个主题(领导与管理、能力建设、政策和指南的实施、宣传/意识和基础设施),这些主题被选定纳入埃塞俄比亚计划生育与艾滋病服务整合的战略行动计划。
研究人员根据多组分析结果制定的战略行动计划,在一次面对面的验证会议上,通过所有相关利益相关者的参与得到了验证。利用不同的名义小组并进行多组名义小组分析的利益相关者参与,确保了战略行动计划的所有权,因为参与制定的人员将是在埃塞俄比亚实施该计划的人员。