E&K Consulting Firm, Nairobi, Kenya.
African Population and Health Research Center, Nairobi, Kenya.
Int J Equity Health. 2022 May 19;21(1):73. doi: 10.1186/s12939-022-01656-x.
Significant progress has been made to advance Maternal, Newborn and Child Health (MNCH) in Ethiopia. Further, the country has enshrined equity as a core value in their strategic and development frameworks and policies. Although national statistics show improved health outcomes, there exists persistent inequities in avoidable health risks and premature deaths. Additionally, the improving health statistics mask the disparities in health outcomes based on education, employment status, income level, gender and ethnicity dimensions.The EquiFrame framework was used to assess the extent to which equity was entrenched in MNCH health policies and plans. The framework, which describes core concepts against which health policies and plans can be assessed, also provides a scoring criterion for policy assessment. The framework was modified to include the concept of intersectionality, which is increasingly gaining significance in the health policy ecosystems. The policies and plans reviewed in this analysis exercise were selected based on (1) their relevance - only policies and plans in force as of the year 2020 were considered; (2) availability in the public domain as this study was limited to desk research; and (3) relevance to MNCH. A total of five policies and plans were analyzed and evaluated against the 15 core concepts presented in the modified EquiFrame framework. Following the outcomes of the assessment, documents were ranked as either being low, moderate, or high, in exhaustively addressing the core concepts.The Ethiopia Health Sector Transformation Plan (2016-2020) is the only policy or plan that earned a high ranking. The other four policies and plans were ranked as moderate. This shows that while majority of the Ethiopian health sector policies and plans exist and address the core health equity concepts, they fail to: (i) spell out plans to implement and monitor the proposed interventions; and (ii) demonstrate evidence that the interventions were implemented or monitored. With the global goal of leaving no one behind, future policy development in Ethiopia needs to prioritize equity considerations in order to enhance the ongoing health improvement.
在推进埃塞俄比亚母婴和儿童健康(MNCH)方面取得了重大进展。此外,该国在其战略和发展框架及政策中将公平作为核心价值观。尽管国家统计数据显示健康状况有所改善,但在可避免的健康风险和过早死亡方面仍然存在不平等现象。此外,改善的健康统计数据掩盖了基于教育、就业状况、收入水平、性别和族裔维度的健康结果差异。EquiFrame 框架用于评估公平在 MNCH 卫生政策和计划中的嵌入程度。该框架描述了可以用来评估卫生政策和计划的核心概念,还为政策评估提供了评分标准。该框架经过修改,纳入了交叉性概念,该概念在卫生政策生态系统中日益受到重视。在本分析工作中审查的政策和计划是基于以下标准选择的:(1) 相关性——仅考虑截至 2020 年有效的政策和计划;(2) 在公共领域的可用性,因为本研究仅限于案头研究;(3) 与 MNCH 的相关性。共分析和评估了五项政策和计划,根据修改后的 EquiFrame 框架中的 15 个核心概念进行评估。根据评估结果,文件被归类为低、中或高,以详尽地解决核心概念。埃塞俄比亚卫生部门转型计划(2016-2020 年)是唯一一项获得高分的政策或计划。其他四项政策和计划被评为中等。这表明,虽然埃塞俄比亚卫生部门的大多数政策和计划都存在并解决了核心的卫生公平概念,但它们未能:(i) 详细说明实施和监测拟议干预措施的计划;(ii) 证明已经实施或监测了干预措施。为了实现全球不让任何人掉队的目标,埃塞俄比亚未来的政策制定需要优先考虑公平因素,以加强正在进行的健康改善。