Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
Division of Biomedical Statistics and Informatics, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2022 Jun 15;104(12):1068-1080. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.21.01171. Epub 2022 Apr 22.
Many risk factors have been described for dislocation following total hip arthroplasty (THA), yet a patient-specific risk assessment tool remains elusive. The purpose of this study was to develop a high-dimensional, patient-specific risk-stratification nomogram that allows dynamic risk modification based on operative decisions.
In this study, 29,349 THAs, including 21,978 primary and 7371 revision cases, performed between 1998 and 2018 were evaluated. During a mean 6-year follow-up, 1521 THAs were followed by a dislocation. Patients were characterized, through individual-chart review, according to non-modifiable factors (demographics, indication for THA, spine disease, prior spine surgery, and neurologic disease) and modifiable operative decisions (operative approach, femoral head diameter, and type of acetabular liner [standard, elevated, constrained, or dual-mobility]). Multivariable regression models and nomograms were developed with dislocation as a binary outcome at 1 year and 5 years postoperatively.
Dislocation risk, based on patient-specific comorbidities and operative decisions, was wide-ranging-from 0.3% to 13% at 1 year and from 0.4% to 19% at 5 years after primary THA, and from 2% to 32% at 1 year and from 3% to 42% at 5 years after revision THA. In the primary-THA group, the direct anterior approach (hazard ratio [HR] = 0.27) and lateral approach (HR = 0.58) decreased the dislocation risk compared with the posterior approach. After adjusting for the approach in that group, the combination of a ≥36-mm-diameter femoral head and an elevated liner yielded the largest decrease in dislocation risk (HR = 0.28), followed by dual-mobility constructs (HR = 0.48). In the patients who underwent revision THA, the adjusted risk of dislocation was most markedly decreased by the use of a dual-mobility construct (HR = 0.40), followed by a ≥36-mm femoral head and an elevated liner (HR = 0.88). The adjusted risk of dislocation after revision THA was decreased by acetabular revision (HR = 0.58), irrespective of whether other components were revised.
Our patient-specific dislocation risk calculator, which was strengthened by our use of a robust multivariable model that accounted for comorbidities associated with instability, demonstrated wide-ranging patient-specific risks based on comorbidity profiles. The resultant nomograms can be used as a screening tool to identify patients at high risk for dislocation following THA and to individualize operative decisions for evidence-based risk mitigation.
Prognostic Level IV. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
全髋关节置换术后(THA)脱位已有多种危险因素被描述,但患者特异性风险评估工具仍难以捉摸。本研究的目的是开发一种高维、患者特异性的风险分层列线图,允许根据手术决策进行动态风险修正。
本研究评估了 1998 年至 2018 年间进行的 29349 例 THA,包括 21978 例初次置换和 7371 例翻修。在平均 6 年的随访中,1521 例 THA 发生脱位。通过个别图表回顾,根据不可变因素(人口统计学、THA 指征、脊柱疾病、脊柱手术史和神经疾病)和可改变的手术决策(手术入路、股骨头直径和髋臼衬垫类型[标准、高边、约束或双动])对患者进行特征描述。使用 1 年和 5 年后的术后脱位作为二元结局,建立多变量回归模型和列线图。
基于患者特定的合并症和手术决策,脱位风险范围很广-初次 THA 后 1 年的风险为 0.3%至 13%,5 年的风险为 0.4%至 19%;初次 THA 后 1 年的风险为 2%至 32%,5 年的风险为 3%至 42%。在初次 THA 组中,直接前入路(风险比[HR] = 0.27)和外侧入路(HR = 0.58)与后路相比降低了脱位风险。在该组中调整了手术入路后,使用≥36mm 股骨头和高边衬垫组合降低脱位风险的效果最大(HR = 0.28),其次是双动结构(HR = 0.48)。在接受翻修 THA 的患者中,使用双动结构(HR = 0.40)可显著降低脱位风险,其次是使用≥36mm 股骨头和高边衬垫(HR = 0.88)。髋臼翻修(HR = 0.58)降低了翻修 THA 后脱位的调整风险,而不论其他组件是否翻修。
我们的患者特异性脱位风险计算器通过使用稳健的多变量模型来加强,该模型考虑了与不稳定相关的合并症,根据合并症谱显示了广泛的患者特异性风险。由此产生的列线图可作为一种筛选工具,用于识别 THA 后脱位风险较高的患者,并为基于证据的风险降低制定个体化手术决策。
预后 IV 级。有关证据水平的完整描述,请参阅作者指南。