El Garhy Mohammad, Owais Tamer, Lauten Philipp
Department of Cardiology, Heart Centre, Zentralklinik Bad Berka, Robert-Koch Allee 9, 99437, Bad Berka, Germany.
Department of Cardiology, Minia University, Minia, Egypt.
Egypt Heart J. 2022 Sep 30;74(1):71. doi: 10.1186/s43044-022-00311-8.
Most of TAVR centers evaluate the calcium score in contrast-enhanced (ce) CT. We compared in this study between different methodologies to measure calcium score. We studied also the difference between patients with low-gradient (LG) and high-gradient (HG) severe aortic stenosis (AS) as regard the burden of aortic valve calcium (AVC).
We measured the calcium volume and score using Agatston methodology in non-contrast (nc) CT and with modified and fixed 850 Hounsfield unit (HU) thresholds in ce CT. The calcium score and volume in ceCT using even with modified thresholds is significantly lower than the assessed score and volume in ncCT. The median (IQR) of calcium score in nc CT and in cc CT were 1288 AU (750-1815) versus 947 HU (384-2202). The median (IQR) of calcium volume in nc CT and in cc CT with modified thresholds were 701 mm (239-1632) versus 197 mm (139-532). Agatston score and calcium volume were lower in patients with LG AS than HG AS; 2069 AU (899-2477) versus 928AU (572-1284) and 1537 mm (644-1860) versus 286 mm (160-700), respectively. Only 20% of patients with LGAS had Agatston score higher than the previously supposed AVC score threshold for the diagnosis of severe AS (> 2000AU in men and > 1200 in women).
The diagnosis of severe LGAS should not depend on a single parameter as calcium score. In these patients, calcium score should be measured in nc CT and not in ce CT.
大多数经导管主动脉瓣置换术(TAVR)中心在对比增强(ce)CT中评估钙化积分。在本研究中,我们比较了测量钙化积分的不同方法。我们还研究了低梯度(LG)和高梯度(HG)重度主动脉瓣狭窄(AS)患者在主动脉瓣钙化(AVC)负担方面的差异。
我们在非对比(nc)CT中使用阿加斯顿方法测量钙化体积和积分,并在ce CT中使用修改后的固定850亨氏单位(HU)阈值进行测量。即使使用修改后的阈值,ceCT中的钙化积分和体积也显著低于ncCT中评估的积分和体积。nc CT和ce CT中钙化积分的中位数(四分位间距)分别为1288 AU(750 - 1815)和947 HU(384 - 2202)。nc CT和使用修改后阈值的ce CT中钙化体积的中位数(四分位间距)分别为701 mm(239 - 1632)和197 mm(139 - 532)。LG AS患者的阿加斯顿积分和钙化体积低于HG AS患者;分别为2069 AU(899 - 2477)和928 AU(572 - 1284),以及1537 mm(644 - 1860)和286 mm(160 - 700)。只有20%的LGAS患者的阿加斯顿积分高于先前假定的用于诊断重度AS的AVC积分阈值(男性>2000AU,女性>1200)。
重度LGAS的诊断不应依赖于单一参数如钙化积分。对于这些患者,应在nc CT而非ce CT中测量钙化积分。