Department of Emergency Medicine, Penn State Hershey Medical Center, Hershey, PennsylvaniaUSA.
Department of Public Health Sciences, Penn State College of Medicine, Hershey, PennsylvaniaUSA.
Prehosp Disaster Med. 2022 Dec;37(6):800-805. doi: 10.1017/S1049023X22001388. Epub 2022 Oct 10.
Wilderness Medicine (WM) focuses on care delivered in austere or resource-scarce environments. The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) requirements and core content for Emergency Medicine (EM) residency and Emergency Medical Services (EMS) fellowship in the United States (US) include some WM topics that are covered to varying degrees in these programs. Furthermore, there are no ACGME-approved WM fellowships or specific curricula. Different training programs may develop WM content and curricula that differ significantly, leading to variations in WM competencies and training. In 2009, the American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) Wilderness Medicine Section created a Fellowship Subcommittee and Taskforce to develop a standardized curriculum and core content for EM-based WM fellowships. However, to date, EMS fellowship and EM residency WM curricula in the US content have not been analyzed for consistency with the ACEP WM fellowship curriculum.
In this study, the WM curricula components of EM residency and EMS fellowship were evaluated using the ACEP WM fellowship curriculum as a control. Potential curriculum gaps for each program type were identified.
Of the 19 WM competencies developed by the ACEP Wilderness Medicine Section Fellowship Subcommittee and Taskforce, EMS fellowship covers more WM topics (16 topics, or 84%) than EM residency (12 topics, or 63%), and combined, they cover 89% of these topics.
By expanding to cover two additional WM topics, all WM curricula topics recommended by the ACEP WM fellowship curriculum could potentially be covered in EM residency + EMS fellowship; however, the depth of education in each topic may vary. It may be beneficial for Graduate Medical Education (GME)-level learners for programs to implement hands-on educational experiences in WM topics.
荒野医学(WM)专注于在恶劣或资源匮乏的环境中提供护理。美国急诊医学(EM)住院医师和急诊医疗服务(EMS)研究员的认证委员会(ACGME)要求和核心内容包括这些项目中不同程度涵盖的一些 WM 主题。此外,没有经过 ACGME 批准的 WM 研究员课程或特定课程。不同的培训计划可能会开发出差异很大的 WM 内容和课程,从而导致 WM 能力和培训的差异。2009 年,美国急诊医师学院(ACEP)荒野医学科成立了研究员分会委员会和工作组,为基于 EM 的 WM 研究员课程制定标准化课程和核心内容。然而,迄今为止,美国 EMS 研究员课程和 EM 住院医师 WM 课程的内容尚未与 ACEP WM 研究员课程进行一致性分析。
在这项研究中,使用 ACEP WM 研究员课程作为对照,评估了 EM 住院医师和 EMS 研究员的 WM 课程组成部分。确定了每个课程类型的潜在课程差距。
ACEP 荒野医学科研究员分会委员会和工作组制定的 19 项 WM 能力中,EMS 研究员涵盖了更多的 WM 主题(16 个主题,占 84%),而 EM 住院医师涵盖了 12 个主题(占 63%),两者结合起来涵盖了这些主题的 89%。
通过扩展涵盖另外两个 WM 主题,所有 ACEP WM 研究员课程推荐的 WM 课程主题都有可能在 EM 住院医师+EMS 研究员中涵盖;然而,每个主题的教育深度可能会有所不同。对于住院医师和 EMS 研究员课程来说,实施 WM 主题的实践教育体验可能对研究生医学教育(GME)学习者有益。