El Bilali Hamid, Berjan Sinisa, Ben Hassen Tarek, Memon Junaid Alam, Vaško Željko, Allahyari Mohammad S
International Centre for Advanced Mediterranean Agronomic Studies (CIHEAM-Bari), Bari, Italy.
Department of Agroeconomy and Rural Development, Faculty of Agriculture, University of East Sarajevo, East Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Front Nutr. 2022 Sep 21;9:983639. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2022.983639. eCollection 2022.
Food losses and waste (FLW) is considered a critical issue in the ongoing debate on the sustainability of agri-food systems. However, the scholarly literature on FLW is still geographically-biased, with more attention devoted to developed countries, even in Europe. In this context, this article analyses the state of research on FLW in the Western Balkan region (viz. Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Montenegro, North Macedonia, and Serbia). A search performed in October 2021 on the Web of Science database returned 34 documents, and 21 eligible ones were included in the systematic review. The topical analysis of the literature addressed causes of FLW, stages of the food supply chain, extent and magnitude of FLW, FLW and food security, economic and environmental impacts of FLW, and food waste (FW) management strategies. A central finding was the scarcity of data on FW in the Western Balkans. Moreover, the literature focused on FW at the consumer level, while food loss at other stages of the food chain was generally overlooked. There is a lack of comprehensive analyses of the economic and environmental impacts of FLW as well as its implications in terms of food and nutrition security. The quantification of FLW is generally inaccurate and based on estimates and self-reported data. The literature focuses on FW reuse and recycling (e.g., energy, compost) while other management strategies (e.g., reduction/prevention, redistribution) are rarely addressed. However, the results indicated that consumers in the Western Balkans pay attention to the FW issue, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, which is an encouraging sign that can be exploited in awareness-raising campaigns and education activities. Meanwhile, research on FLW in the Western Balkans is highly needed to fill the identified knowledge gap and provide evidence to policies dealing with the transition to sustainable food systems in the region.
食品损失和浪费(FLW)在当前关于农业食品系统可持续性的辩论中被视为一个关键问题。然而,关于FLW的学术文献仍存在地域偏见,即使在欧洲,也更多地关注发达国家。在此背景下,本文分析了西巴尔干地区(即波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那、克罗地亚、黑山、北马其顿和塞尔维亚)FLW的研究现状。2021年10月在科学网数据库中进行的搜索返回了34篇文献,其中21篇符合条件的文献被纳入系统评价。对文献的主题分析涉及FLW的原因、食品供应链阶段、FLW的范围和规模、FLW与粮食安全、FLW的经济和环境影响以及食品浪费(FW)管理策略。一个核心发现是西巴尔干地区FW数据稀缺。此外,文献聚焦于消费者层面的FW,而食物链其他阶段的食品损失通常被忽视。缺乏对FLW的经济和环境影响及其在粮食和营养安全方面的影响的全面分析。FLW的量化通常不准确,且基于估计和自我报告的数据。文献关注FW的再利用和回收(如能源、堆肥),而很少涉及其他管理策略(如减少/预防、再分配)。然而,结果表明,西巴尔干地区的消费者关注FW问题,尤其是在新冠疫情期间,这是一个令人鼓舞的迹象,可用于提高认识运动和教育活动。与此同时,西巴尔干地区迫切需要开展关于FLW的研究,以填补已发现的知识空白,并为该地区向可持续食品系统转型的政策提供证据。