School of Journalism and Graphic Communication, Florida A&M University.
Health Commun. 2023 Dec;38(13):2956-2970. doi: 10.1080/10410236.2022.2129243. Epub 2022 Oct 10.
With COVID-19's unprecedented impact and ongoing debates on prosocial social distancing and antisocial beach crowd gathering, this study examined the roles of social desirability, social distance marked by race, and social identity in the third-person effect (TPE) of COVID-related news concerning risk perception among Historically Black College and University (HBCU) students. The findings confirmed third- and first-person effects with the perceived influence of antisocial (beach partying) news greater for others than themselves, whereas the self was perceived to be more responsive to the influence of prosocial (social distancing) news. A symmetric interaction between social desirability and social identity indicated that the racial out-group, non-HBCU students in Florida were perceived as more affected by antisocial beach party news, whereas the in-group HBCU peers were perceived as more influenced by desirable social distancing warning news and COVID news in general. The first-person perception and shrunk self-other gap in COVID news influence on HBCU students" concerns may be associated with perceived personal vulnerability and responsibility as well as a political reflection on the government's handling of COVID. While they presumed favorable media influence on self and the in-group to preserve collective self-esteem, they made realistic threat judgments from perceiving undesirable media influence on their in-group peers' risky behavior tendency and intended to take preventive actions (staying home) to avoid the health risk. Further, it was the first-person perceptual gap between themselves and the out-group, non-HBCU students that influenced them to heed social distancing warnings.
鉴于 COVID-19 前所未有的影响,以及关于亲社会社交距离和反社会海滩人群聚集的持续争论,本研究考察了社会期望、种族标志的社会距离以及社会认同在 COVID 相关新闻的第三人效果(TPE)中对 HBCU 学生风险感知的作用。研究结果证实了第三人和第一人称效果,即认为反社会(海滩派对)新闻对他人的影响大于对自己的影响,而自己则被认为更容易受到亲社会(社交距离)新闻的影响。社会期望和社会认同之间的对称相互作用表明,外群体(佛罗里达州的非 HBCU 学生)被认为更容易受到反社会海滩派对新闻的影响,而内群体 HBCU 同伴则更容易受到理想的社交距离警告新闻和 COVID 一般新闻的影响。HBCU 学生对 COVID 新闻影响的第一人称感知和自我-他人差距缩小,可能与个人脆弱性和责任感以及对政府处理 COVID 的政治反思有关。虽然他们认为有利的媒体对自己和内群体的影响可以维护集体自尊,但他们从对自己内群体同伴冒险行为倾向的不良媒体影响的感知中做出了现实的威胁判断,并打算采取预防措施(待在家里)以避免健康风险。此外,正是他们自己和外群体(非 HBCU 学生)之间的第一人称感知差距促使他们关注社交距离警告。