The Canadian Observatory On Homelessness 6Th Floor Kaneff Tower, York University, 4700 Keele St, Toronto, ON, M3J 1P3, Canada.
Institute of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Carleton University, Ottawa, ON, K1S 5B6, Canada.
Syst Rev. 2022 Oct 15;11(1):223. doi: 10.1186/s13643-022-02089-x.
The COVID-19 pandemic has disproportionately impacted homeless populations and service workers, especially within homeless shelter/hostel settings. To date, there have been few evidence syntheses examining outbreaks of COVID-19 among both homeless shelter residents and service workers and no critical review of infection control and prevention (IPAC) measures. This scoping review offers a much-needed synthesis of COVID-19 prevalence within homeless shelters and a review of pertinent IPAC measures. METHODS: We conducted a scoping review that aimed to synthesize academic and gray literature published from March 2020 to July 2021 pertaining to (1) the prevalence of COVID-19 among both residents and staff in homeless shelters and hostels in high-income countries and (2) COVID-19 IPAC strategies applied in these settings. Two reviewers independently screened the literature from several databases that included MEDLINE, PsycInfo, and the WHO's COVID-19 Global Health Portal. The extracted data was mapped, categorized, and thematically discussed.
Thematic analysis of 77 academic and gray literature documents revealed four key themes: (1) the demographics of COVID-19 in homeless shelters, (2) asymptomatic spread, (3) pre-existing vulnerability of people experiencing homelessness and shelters, and (4) the inconsistency and ineffectiveness of IPAC implementation.
This review offers a useful glimpse into the landscape of COVID-19 outbreaks in homeless shelters/hostels and the major contributing factors to these events. This review revealed that there is no clear indication of generally accepted IPAC standards for shelter residents and workers. This review also illustrated a great need for future research to establish IPAC best practices specifically for homeless shelter/hostel contexts. Finally, the findings from this review reaffirm that homelessness prevention is key to limiting disease outbreaks and the associated negative health outcomes in shelter populations. Limitations of this review included the temporal and database constraints of the search strategy, the exclusion of quality assessments of the literature, and the absence of investigation on the influence of emerging variants on public health policy.
This scoping review has not been registered on any database; the protocol is available on York University's Institutional Repository https://dx.doi.org/10.25071/10315/38513 .
COVID-19 大流行对无家可归者和服务人员造成了不成比例的影响,尤其是在无家可归者收容所/宿舍环境中。迄今为止,几乎没有关于 COVID-19 在无家可归者收容所居民和服务人员中爆发的综合证据,也没有对感染控制和预防 (IPC) 措施的批判性审查。这项范围界定审查提供了对无家可归者收容所中 COVID-19 流行情况的急需综合,并对相关 IPC 措施进行了审查。
我们进行了一项范围界定审查,旨在综合 2020 年 3 月至 2021 年 7 月期间发表的学术和灰色文献,内容涉及 (1) 高收入国家无家可归者收容所和宿舍居民和工作人员中 COVID-19 的流行情况,以及 (2) 在这些环境中应用的 COVID-19 IPC 策略。两名审查员独立筛选了来自多个数据库的文献,其中包括 MEDLINE、PsycInfo 和世界卫生组织的 COVID-19 全球卫生门户。提取的数据被映射、分类和主题讨论。
对 77 篇学术和灰色文献的主题分析揭示了四个关键主题:(1) 无家可归者收容所中 COVID-19 的人口统计学特征,(2) 无症状传播,(3) 无家可归者和收容所预先存在的脆弱性,以及 (4) IPC 实施的不一致和无效性。
本综述提供了对无家可归者收容所/宿舍中 COVID-19 爆发情况以及这些事件的主要促成因素的有用了解。本综述表明,对于收容所居民和工作人员,没有明确表明存在普遍接受的 IPC 标准。本综述还说明了对特定于无家可归者收容所/宿舍环境的 IPC 最佳实践进行未来研究的迫切需要。最后,本综述的研究结果再次证实,预防无家可归是限制疾病爆发和收容所人群相关不良健康后果的关键。本综述的局限性包括搜索策略的时间和数据库限制、文献质量评估的排除以及对新兴变异对公共卫生政策影响的调查缺失。
本范围界定审查尚未在任何数据库中注册;该方案可在约克大学机构知识库中获得 https://dx.doi.org/10.25071/10315/38513 。