Borgbjerg Jens, Christensen Heidi S, Al-Mashhadi Rozh, Bøgsted Martin, Frøkjær Jens B, Medrud Lise, Larsen Nis Elbrønd, Lindholt Jes S
Department of Radiology, Akershus University Hospital, Oslo, Norway.
Department of Radiology, Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark.
Acta Radiol Open. 2022 Oct 12;11(10):20584601221132461. doi: 10.1177/20584601221132461. eCollection 2022 Oct.
Routine CT scans may increasingly be used to document normal aortic size and to detect incidental abdominal aortic aneurysms.
To determine whether ultra-low-dose non-contrast CT (ULDNC-CT) can be used instead of the gold standard CT angiography (CTA) for assessment of maximal abdominal aortic diameter.
This retrospective study included 50 patients who underwent CTA and a normal-dose non-contrast CT for suspected renal artery stenosis. ULDNC-CT datasets were generated from the normal-dose non-contrast CT datasets using a simulation technique. Using the centerline technique, radiology consultants ( = 4) and residents ( = 3) determined maximal abdominal aortic diameter. The limits of agreement with the mean (LOAM) was used to access observer agreement. LOAM represents how much a measurement by a single observer may plausibly deviate from the mean of all observers on the specific subject.
Observers completed 1400 measurements encompassing repeated CTA and ULDNC-CT measurements. The mean diameter was 24.0 and 25.0 mm for CTA and ULDNC-CT, respectively, yielding a significant but minor mean difference of 1.0 mm. The 95% LOAM reproducibility was similar for CTA and ULDNC-CT (2.3 vs 2.3 mm). In addition, the 95% LOAM and mean diameters were similar for CTA and ULDNC-CT when observers were grouped as consultants and residents.
Ultra-low-dose non-contrast CT exhibited similar accuracy and reproducibility of measurements compared with CTA for assessing maximal abdominal aortic diameter supporting that ULDNC-CT can be used interchangeably with CTA in the lower range of aortic sizes.
常规CT扫描可能越来越多地用于记录正常主动脉大小以及检测偶然发现的腹主动脉瘤。
确定超低剂量非增强CT(ULDNC-CT)是否可替代金标准CT血管造影(CTA)用于评估腹主动脉最大直径。
这项回顾性研究纳入了50例因疑似肾动脉狭窄而接受CTA和常规剂量非增强CT检查的患者。使用模拟技术从常规剂量非增强CT数据集中生成ULDNC-CT数据集。采用中心线技术,放射科会诊医生(=4)和住院医师(=3)确定腹主动脉最大直径。使用一致性界限均值(LOAM)来评估观察者间的一致性。LOAM表示单个观察者的测量值与特定受试者所有观察者测量均值可能合理偏离的程度。
观察者完成了1400次测量,包括重复的CTA和ULDNC-CT测量。CTA和ULDNC-CT的平均直径分别为24.0和25.0mm,平均差异为1.0mm,差异显著但较小。CTA和ULDNC-CT的95%LOAM重复性相似(2.3对2.3mm)。此外,当将观察者分为会诊医生和住院医师时,CTA和ULDNC-CT的95%LOAM和平均直径相似。
在评估腹主动脉最大直径方面,超低剂量非增强CT与CTA相比显示出相似的测量准确性和可重复性,这支持在主动脉尺寸较低范围内ULDNC-CT可与CTA互换使用。