Maddahi J, Crues J, Berman D S, Mericle J, Becerra A, Garcia E V, Henderson R, Bradley W
J Am Coll Cardiol. 1987 Sep;10(3):682-92. doi: 10.1016/s0735-1097(87)80213-9.
The validity of cardiac nuclear magnetic resonance imaging for determination of left ventricular myocardial mass was evaluated in nine dogs. A gated spin echo-pulsing sequence was used for in vivo imaging, obtaining 0.7 cm thick slices of the heart spaced by 1 cm. On each imaged slice, the left ventricular surface area was reproducibly determined by planimetry and was multiplied by slice spacing and specific gravity of the myocardium (1.05) to obtain slice mass. Total left ventricular mass was calculated by adding slice masses in short-axis (method I), transaxial (method II) and vertical long-axis (method III) orientations using Simpson's rule. With each method, masses of the portions of the left ventricle subject to partial volume effect either were not accounted for or alternatively were estimated from the same or an orthogonal imaging plane. Calculated left ventricular mass was compared with the actual excised left ventricular weight. With NMR imaging of in situ nonbeating hearts, best results were obtained when either method I or method II was used and partial volume effect was estimated either from the same or an orthogonal plane. With in vivo NMR imaging, best results were noted when method I was used and mass of the partial volume apex was calculated from transaxial slices: Y (in vivo NMR image) = 8.3 + 0.99X, r = 0.996, SEE = 3.14. For this method, the interobserver reliability coefficient and standard error of the measurement were 0.97 and 5.4, respectively. Compared with method I, in vivo methods II and III were associated with larger errors (SEE ranging from 13.03 to 19.03) regardless of the approach used to estimate partial volume effect. It is concluded that NMR imaging is a highly accurate noninvasive method for in vivo measurement of left ventricular mass in dogs and offers promise for accurate measurement of left ventricular mass in patients.
在9只犬中评估了心脏核磁共振成像用于测定左心室心肌质量的有效性。采用门控自旋回波脉冲序列进行体内成像,获取厚度为0.7 cm、间隔为1 cm的心脏切片。在每个成像切片上,通过平面测量法可重复地测定左心室表面积,并将其乘以切片间隔和心肌比重(1.05)以获得切片质量。使用辛普森法则,通过将短轴(方法I)、横轴(方法II)和垂直长轴(方法III)方向的切片质量相加来计算左心室总质量。对于每种方法,受部分容积效应影响的左心室部分的质量要么未被考虑,要么从相同或正交成像平面进行估计。将计算得到的左心室质量与实际切除的左心室重量进行比较。对于原位非跳动心脏的核磁共振成像,当使用方法I或方法II并从相同或正交平面估计部分容积效应时,可获得最佳结果。对于体内核磁共振成像,当使用方法I并从横轴切片计算部分容积心尖的质量时,可获得最佳结果:Y(体内核磁共振图像)= 8.3 + 0.99X,r = 0.996,标准误(SEE)= 3.14。对于该方法,观察者间可靠性系数和测量标准误分别为0.97和5.4。与方法I相比,无论用于估计部分容积效应的方法如何,体内方法II和III的误差都更大(标准误范围为13.03至19.03)。结论是,核磁共振成像对于犬体内左心室质量的测量是一种高度准确的非侵入性方法,并且有望用于准确测量患者的左心室质量。