Sullivan Breanna, Platt Brooks, Joiner Josh, Jacobs Cale, Conley Caitlin, Landy David C, Stone Austin V
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery and Sports Medicine, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY, USA.
HSS J. 2022 Nov;18(4):485-489. doi: 10.1177/15563316221089930. Epub 2022 May 3.
Stem cell therapies have emerged as a potential treatment for osteoarthritis (OA), but their role remains controversial. Their growing popularity may lead patients to search for information online, but search queries and sources are unknown.
We sought to (1) identify the most frequently asked questions on Google related to knee OA and stem cell therapy, (2) assess the types of websites accessed through these searches, and (3) evaluate the transparency of these websites.
The search terms "knee," "osteoarthritis," and "stem cell" were entered into Google. Frequently asked questions suggested by Google, and their corresponding websites were extracted. Questions and websites were classified by type. () benchmark criteria were used as a measure of website transparency (range: 0-4). Analysis of variance tests were performed to compare benchmark criteria between website types.
Of the 145 questions and website extracted, the most common question subtype pertained to non-stem cell treatments (41.4%) for knee OA; the most common website types were medical publishers (24.8%) and nonacademic medical practices (22.8%). scores were highest for medical publishers (mean: 3.81) and lowest for nonacademic medical practices (mean: 1.55). Nonacademic medical practices had significantly worse scores compared with commercial, academic, and medical publishers.
The most frequent questions pertained to non-stem cell treatments, although questions related to stem cell efficacy were most common among the 10 most frequent questions. Google searches on knee OA and stem cell therapies often directed the user to websites lacking transparency and verifiable information. Further research is warranted.
干细胞疗法已成为骨关节炎(OA)的一种潜在治疗方法,但其作用仍存在争议。它们越来越受欢迎可能会导致患者在网上搜索信息,但搜索查询和来源尚不清楚。
我们试图(1)确定谷歌上与膝骨关节炎和干细胞疗法相关的最常见问题,(2)评估通过这些搜索访问的网站类型,以及(3)评估这些网站的透明度。
在谷歌中输入搜索词“膝盖”“骨关节炎”和“干细胞”。提取谷歌建议的常见问题及其相应网站。问题和网站按类型分类。使用基准标准作为网站透明度的衡量指标(范围:0 - 4)。进行方差分析测试以比较不同网站类型之间的基准标准。
在提取的145个问题和网站中,膝骨关节炎最常见的问题子类型与非干细胞治疗有关(41.4%);最常见的网站类型是医学出版商(24.8%)和非学术医疗实践机构(22.8%)。医学出版商的得分最高(平均:3.81),非学术医疗实践机构的得分最低(平均:1.55)。与商业、学术和医学出版商相比,非学术医疗实践机构的得分明显更差。
最常见问题与非干细胞治疗有关,尽管在最常见的10个问题中与干细胞疗效相关的问题最为普遍。在谷歌上搜索膝骨关节炎和干细胞疗法常常会将用户导向缺乏透明度和可验证信息的网站。有必要进行进一步研究。