Warren John Robert, Halpern-Manners Andrew, Helgertz Jonas
Department of Sociology, Minnesota Population Center, 909 Social Sciences, 267 19th Ave N, University of Minnesota, USA.
Department of Sociology, Indiana University, USA.
SSM Popul Health. 2022 Sep 28;19:101233. doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2022.101233. eCollection 2022 Sep.
There is considerable evidence that the act of participating in a survey can alter participants' attitudes, behaviors, and other outcomes in meaningful ways. Considering findings that this form of panel conditioning also impacts health behaviors and outcomes, we investigated the effect of participating in an intensive half-century-long cohort study on participants' longevity. To do so, we used data from a 1957 survey of more than 33,000 Wisconsin high school seniors linked to mortality records. One third of those people were selected at random to participate in the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study (WLS); the other two thirds were never again contacted. Our survival models show no evidence of panel conditioning effects on longevity: People selected at random to participate in the WLS had the same mortality outcomes as their peers who were not selected. This finding holds for the full sample, for women, for men, for population subgroups defined by family socioeconomic origins and educational experiences, and for treatment compliers.
有大量证据表明,参与调查的行为能够以有意义的方式改变参与者的态度、行为及其他结果。鉴于这种形式的样本调整也会影响健康行为和结果,我们调查了参与一项长达半个世纪的密集队列研究对参与者寿命的影响。为此,我们使用了1957年对33000多名威斯康星州高中高年级学生的调查数据,并将其与死亡记录相联系。这些人中的三分之一被随机挑选出来参与威斯康星纵向研究(WLS);另外三分之二则再也没有被联系过。我们的生存模型没有显示出样本调整对寿命有影响的证据:被随机挑选参与WLS的人与未被挑选的同龄人有相同的死亡结果。这一发现适用于全样本、女性、男性、由家庭社会经济出身和教育经历定义的人口亚组以及治疗依从者。