Rachdi Rim, Hannachi Souha, Zribi Sabrine, Ayed Oumaima, Abid Rim, Moatemri Zied, Mhamdi Samira, Dabboussi Salsabil, Gharsallah Hédi, Sellami Walid, Sammoud Walid, Massoudi Hakim, Lamine Khaled, Djebbi Olfa, Hammami Rim, Ben Moussa Mohamed, Bellaaj Ridha, Battikh Riadh, Rachdi Mohamed Radhouane, Ferjani Mustapha
Service d'hygiène hospitalière et de protection de l'environnement, Hôpital militaire principal d'instruction de Tunis (HMPIT), 1008 Montfleury, Tunis, Tunisie.
Service des maladies infectieuses, HMPIT.
Med Trop Sante Int. 2022 Aug 18;2(3). doi: 10.48327/mtsi.v2i3.2022.207. eCollection 2022 Sep 30.
Since December 2019, a novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) has triggered a global pandemic with a heavy medical and societal-economic toll. The health consequences were not similar during the successive waves that affected several countries. The aim of our study was to compare the sociodemographic, clinical and evolutionary features of COVID-19 patients hospitalized at the Military Hospital of Tunis (HMPIT) during the 2 and 3 waves that affected the country.
Observational prospective study involving 1,527 COVID-19 patients hospitalized at HMPIT over 11 months, divided into two periods: from July 2020 to December 2020 called the second wave (V2) and from January 2021 to May 2021 called the third wave (V3). We compared the epidemiological data, the clinical form and the evolution of the patients for each period.
The number of hospitalized patients was 636 during V2 compared to 891 during V3. Average age was 63.5 ± 15.3 years during V2 65.8 ± 17.8 years during V3 (P = not significant [NS]). The percentage of young adults [18-40 years] was 6.5% during V2 compared to 6.7% during V3 (P = NS). The gender ratio (M/F) was 1.59 for V2 and 1.42 for V3 (P = NS). Comorbidities were present in 65% of V2 patients and 66.3% of V3 patients (P = NS), with hypertension being the most prevalent one in both groups (47.2% for V2 44.9% for V3; P = NS), followed by overweight, dyslipidemia and diabetes (33% for V2 39.3% for V3; P = 0.012). The median duration between symptoms onset and hospitalization was 7 days [5-10] during V2 8.5 days during V3 [5-12] (P = 0.0004). The severe clinical form was present in 49% of patients admitted during V2 compared to 34.8% during V3 (P < 10). The critical form represented 18.6% of cases during V2 against 16.8% during V3 (P = NS). The average hospital length of stay in COVID units (outside of intensive care unit) was 8.4 ± 5.4 days during V2 and 9.8 ± 5.7 days during V3. The average length of stay was significantly longer for the intensive care unit (11.3 ± 3.4 days for V2 13.8 ± 3.9 days for V3; P = 0.01). The case fatality rate was 24.5% during V2 and 20.7% during V3 (P = NS). Median age of death was 70.2 years [42-88] during V2 and 70.4 years [22-96] during V3 with 2 patients less than 40 years of age (1%) for the latter period. The gender ratio (M/F) of deceased patients was 3.21 for V2 and 1.5 for V3 (P = 0.001). The case fatality rate was higher in the intensive care unit (65.4% for V2 69.7% for V3; P = NS). Causes of death were dominated by ARDS (acute respiratory distress syndrome) for both periods (55.1% for V2 70.8% for V3; P = 0.002), followed by septic shock (12.8% for V2 10.8% for V3; P = NS) and multi-organ failure (9.6% for V2 7.0% for V3; P = NS).
This study revealed a decrease in severe and critical clinical forms during the 3rd wave, as well as a decrease in the case fatality rate compared to the previous wave, due to improved management and vaccination. On the other hand, the percentage of ARDS was significantly higher during this wave probably related to the beginning of circulation in our country of the Delta variant causing more severe clinical cases.
自2019年12月以来,一种新型冠状病毒(SARS-CoV-2)引发了一场全球大流行,造成了沉重的医疗和社会经济损失。在影响多个国家的连续几波疫情中,健康后果并不相同。我们研究的目的是比较在突尼斯军事医院(HMPIT)住院的新冠肺炎患者在该国第二波和第三波疫情期间的社会人口统计学、临床和演变特征。
前瞻性观察性研究,涉及11个月内在HMPIT住院的1527例新冠肺炎患者,分为两个时期:2020年7月至2020年12月称为第二波(V2),2021年1月至2021年5月称为第三波(V3)。我们比较了每个时期患者的流行病学数据、临床症状和病情演变。
V2期间住院患者为636例,V3期间为891例。V2期间患者平均年龄为63.5±15.3岁,V3期间为65.8±17.8岁(P=无显著差异[NS])。V2期间18至40岁的年轻人比例为6.5%,V3期间为6.7%(P=NS)。V2的性别比(男/女)为1.59,V3为1.42(P=NS)。65%的V2患者和66.3%的V3患者存在合并症(P=NS),两组中高血压最为常见(V2为47.2%,V3为44.9%;P=NS),其次是超重、血脂异常和糖尿病(V2为33%,V3为39.3%;P=0.012)。症状出现至住院的中位时间在V2期间为7天[5 - 10],V3期间为8.5天[5 - 12](P=0.0004)。V2期间入院患者中49%表现为重症临床症状,V3期间为34.8%(P<0.1)。危重症在V2期间占病例的18.6%,V3期间为16.8%(P=NS)。新冠肺炎病房(非重症监护病房)的平均住院时间在V2期间为8.4±5.4天,V3期间为9.8±5.7天。重症监护病房的平均住院时间明显更长(V2为11.3±3.4天,V3为13.8±3.9天;P=0.01)。V2期间病死率为24.5%,V3期间为20.7%(P=NS)。V2期间死亡患者的中位年龄为70.2岁[42 - 88],V3期间为70.4岁[22 - 96],后一时期有2例年龄小于40岁(1%)。死亡患者的性别比(男/女)V2为3.21(P=0.001)。重症监护病房的病死率更高(V2为65.4%,V3为69.7%;P=NS)。两个时期的主要死亡原因均为急性呼吸窘迫综合征(ARDS)(V2为55.1%,V3为70.8%;P=0.002),其次是感染性休克(V2为12.8%,V3为10.8%;P=NS)和多器官功能衰竭(V2为9.6%,V3为7.0%;P=NS)。
本研究显示,由于管理改善和疫苗接种,第三波疫情期间重症和危重症临床症状减少,病死率也较上一波有所下降。另一方面,这一波疫情期间ARDS的比例显著更高,可能与我国开始传播导致更严重临床病例的德尔塔变异毒株有关。