Santos Isabel M, Silva André, Bem-Haja Pedro, Rosa Catarina, Cerri Luíza, Queiroz Diâner F, Barroso Talles, Alves Miguel F, Silva Carlos F
William James Center for Research, University of Aveiro, 3810-193 Aveiro, Portugal.
Department of Education and Psychology, University of Aveiro, 3810-193 Aveiro, Portugal.
Brain Sci. 2022 Oct 13;12(10):1385. doi: 10.3390/brainsci12101385.
Sleep has a major impact on a variety of human biological and cognitive functions. In particular, its impact on memory has attracted extensive research and has been amply demonstrated. However, it is still unclear whether sleep, or lack thereof, affects the ability to recognize faces. To clarify this, we conducted a scoping review on studies that included a face recognition memory task and any kind of sleep manipulation in adults without any sleep pathology. A systematic search and synthesis of peer-reviewed journal articles identified through the electronic databases Scopus, Web of Science, EBSCO, and PubMed was performed. A final sample of 18 articles, corresponding to 19 studies, met the eligibility criteria. The results of 13 articles suggested that sleep benefited face recognition ability, whereas two articles indicated a detrimental effect of sleep on performance, and four articles found no significant effects. This review highlights the high methodological variability between studies, in terms of sleep manipulation, retention interval, tasks used to probe face recognition, and other variables. In sum, although around one third of the studies show a beneficial effect of sleep on memory for faces, we suggest that future research should invest in replicating these findings with a stricter control of potentially confounding variables to allow stronger conclusions to be drawn.
睡眠对人类多种生物和认知功能有重大影响。尤其是,其对记忆的影响已吸引了广泛研究并得到充分证实。然而,睡眠或睡眠缺失是否会影响面部识别能力仍不明确。为阐明这一点,我们对包含面部识别记忆任务以及对无任何睡眠病理状况的成年人进行的任何形式睡眠操控的研究进行了一项范围综述。通过电子数据库Scopus、科学网、EBSCO和PubMed对同行评审期刊文章进行了系统检索和综合分析。最终有18篇文章(对应19项研究)符合纳入标准。13篇文章的结果表明睡眠有益于面部识别能力,而两篇文章表明睡眠对表现有不利影响,还有四篇文章未发现显著影响。本综述强调了研究之间在睡眠操控、保持间隔、用于探测面部识别的任务以及其他变量方面存在高度的方法学差异。总之,尽管约三分之一的研究表明睡眠对面部记忆有有益影响,但我们建议未来研究应投入精力,通过更严格控制潜在混杂变量来重复这些发现,以便得出更有力的结论。