Kalinowski Rafał, Pisz Anna, Kolinger Dominik, Wilk Michał, Stastny Petr, Krzysztofik Michał
Department of Exercise and Sport Performance, The Jerzy Kukuczka Academy of Physical Education in Katowice, Katowice, Poland.
Faculty of Physical Education and Sport, Charles University, Prague, Czechia.
Front Physiol. 2022 Oct 11;13:1025839. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2022.1025839. eCollection 2022.
This study aimed to compare the effects of bilateral and unilateral conditioning activities (CA; combined isometric and plyometric) on countermovement jump performance, modified t-agility test, Achilles tendon stiffness and skin surface temperature. Thirteen female semi-professional volleyball players performed two CAs in random order: 1) bilateral isometric half back squats followed by bilateral drop jumps (BI-CA); and 2) unilateral isometric half back squats followed by unilateral drop jumps (UNI-CA). To assess the effects of CAs, countermovement jump, modified t-agility test, Achilles tendon stiffness and skin surface temperature measurements were performed 5 min before and 6 min after the CA. Both CAs significantly increased thigh skin surface temperature from pre- to post-CA (BI-CA, < 0.001; effect size [ES] = 1.41 and UNI-CA, = 0.001; ES = 1.39) but none of them influenced modified t-agility test time (interaction: = 0.338, main effect of time: = 0.121 and condition: = 0.819). The countermovement jump height and modified reactive strength index significantly increased from pre-to post-CA during the BI-CA condition ( = 0.003, ES = 0.45, and = 0.008, ES = 0.48) but not for UNI-CA ( = 0.061, ES = 0.18 and = 0.065, ES = 0.26). No significant impact has been found for countermovement depth (interaction: = 0.054, main effect of time: 0.097, and condition: = 0.41) as well as for contraction time (interaction: = 0.536, main effect of time: = 0.224, and condition: = 0.807). Moreover, stronger and weaker limb CMJ relative peak force significantly decreased from pre-to post-CA ( = 0.014, ES = -0.31, and = 0.027, ES = -0.26; respectively) during UNI-CA condition but not for BI-CA ( = 0.096, ES = 0.23, and = 1.41, ES = 0.18). The stronger and weaker limb Achilles tendon stiffness significantly increased from pre-to post-CA during the UNI-CA condition ( = 0.013, ES = 0.60 and < 0.001, ES = 0.79; respectively) but not for BI-CA ( = 0.66; ES = 0.15 and = 0.265; ES = 0.42). Furthermore, the post-CA stronger limb Achilles tendon stiffness during the UNI-CA was significantly higher than that noted during the BI-CA ( = 0.006, ES = 0.7). The present study showed that combined isometric and plyometric bilateral CA effectively improved the countermovement jump but did not enhance the t-agility test performance. These findings indicate that exercise combinations could effectively produce a post-activation performance enhancement effect but should replicate the following explosive task as much as possible.
本研究旨在比较双侧和单侧的条件性活动(CA;等长收缩与增强式收缩相结合)对反向运动跳跃性能、改良t敏捷性测试、跟腱僵硬度和皮肤表面温度的影响。13名女性半职业排球运动员以随机顺序进行了两项CA:1)双侧等长半蹲后接双侧纵跳(BI-CA);2)单侧等长半蹲后接单侧纵跳(UNI-CA)。为评估CA的效果,在CA前5分钟和CA后6分钟进行反向运动跳跃、改良t敏捷性测试、跟腱僵硬度和皮肤表面温度测量。两项CA均使大腿皮肤表面温度从CA前显著升高至CA后(BI-CA,<0.001;效应量[ES]=1.41;UNI-CA,=0.001;ES=1.39),但均未影响改良t敏捷性测试时间(交互作用:=0.338,时间主效应:=0.121,条件主效应:=0.819)。在BI-CA条件下,反向运动跳跃高度和改良反应力量指数从CA前到CA后显著增加(=0.003,ES=0.45;=0.008,ES=0.48),但UNI-CA条件下未增加(=0.061,ES=0.18;=0.065,ES=0.26)。反向运动深度(交互作用:=0.054,时间主效应:0.097,条件主效应:=0.41)以及收缩时间(交互作用:=0.536,时间主效应:=0.224,条件主效应:=0.807)均未发现显著影响。此外,在UNI-CA条件下,优势侧和非优势侧CMJ相对峰值力从CA前到CA后显著降低(分别为=0.014,ES=-0.31;=0.027,ES=-0.26),但BI-CA条件下未降低(=0.096,ES=0.23;=1.41,ES=0.18)。在UNI-CA条件下,优势侧和非优势侧跟腱僵硬度从CA前到CA后显著增加(分别为=0.013,ES=0.60;<0.001,ES=0.79),但BI-CA条件下未增加(=0.66;ES=0.15;=0.265;ES=0.42)。此外,UNI-CA条件下CA后优势侧跟腱僵硬度显著高于BI-CA条件下(=0.006,ES=0.7)。本研究表明,等长收缩与增强式收缩相结合的双侧CA能有效改善反向运动跳跃,但不能提高t敏捷性测试性能。这些发现表明,运动组合可有效产生激活后性能增强效应,但应尽可能复制随后的爆发性任务。