Department of Sport and Health Sciences, Chair of Human Movement Science, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany.
TUM School of Computation, Information and Technology, Chair of Information-Oriented Control, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany.
Sci Rep. 2022 Oct 28;12(1):18128. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-22996-2.
To investigate the proposed association between soccer heading and deleterious brain changes, an accurate quantification of heading exposure is crucial. While wearable sensors constitute a popular means for this task, available systems typically overestimate the number of headers by poorly discriminating true impacts from spurious recordings. This study investigated the utility of a neural network for automatically detecting soccer headers from kinematic time series data obtained by wearable sensors. During 26 matches, 27 female soccer players wore head impacts sensors to register on-field impact events (> 8 g), which were labelled as valid headers (VH) or non-headers (NH) upon video review. Of these ground truth data, subsets of 49% and 21% each were used to train and validate a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) neural network in order to classify sensor recordings as either VH or NH based on their characteristic linear acceleration features. When tested on a balanced dataset comprising 271 VHs and NHs (which corresponds to 30% and 1.4% of ground truth VHs and NHs, respectively), the network showed very good overall classification performance by reaching scores of more than 90% across all metrics. When testing was performed on an unbalanced dataset comprising 271 VHs and 5743 NHs (i.e., 30% of ground truth VHs and NHs, respectively), as typically obtained in real-life settings, the model still achieved over 90% sensitivity and specificity, but only 42% precision, which would result in an overestimation of soccer players' true heading exposure. Although classification performance suffered from the considerable class imbalance between actual headers and non-headers, this study demonstrates the general ability of a data-driven deep learning network to automatically classify soccer headers based on their linear acceleration profiles.
为了探究足球顶球与有害脑变化之间的关联,精确量化顶球暴露至关重要。虽然可穿戴传感器是一种常用的手段,但现有的系统通常无法很好地区分真实撞击和虚假记录,从而高估顶球次数。本研究旨在探讨利用神经网络从可穿戴传感器获得的运动学时间序列数据中自动检测足球顶球的方法。在 26 场比赛中,27 名女性足球运动员佩戴头部撞击传感器记录场上撞击事件(>8g),然后通过视频回放将这些撞击事件标记为有效顶球(VH)或无效顶球(NH)。利用其中 49%和 21%的地面实况数据子集,分别训练和验证长短期记忆(LSTM)神经网络,以便根据传感器记录的特征线性加速度特征将其分类为 VH 或 NH。当在一个包含 271 个 VH 和 NH 的平衡数据集上进行测试时(分别对应于地面实况 VH 和 NH 的 30%和 1.4%),该网络在所有指标上的整体分类性能都非常好,得分均超过 90%。当在一个包含 271 个 VH 和 5743 个 NH 的不平衡数据集(即地面实况 VH 和 NH 的 30%和 1.4%)上进行测试时,模型仍能达到 90%以上的敏感性和特异性,但仅为 42%的精确性,这可能导致对足球运动员真实顶球暴露的高估。尽管分类性能受到实际顶球和非顶球之间的严重类别不平衡的影响,但本研究证明了基于线性加速度分布自动分类足球顶球的基于数据的深度学习网络的一般能力。