El Yamani N, Rundén-Pran E, Collins A R, Longhin E M, Elje E, Hoet P, Vinković Vrček I, Doak S H, Fessard V, Dusinska M
Health Effects Laboratory, Department for Environmental Chemistry, NILU-Norwegian Institute for Air Research, Kjeller, Norway.
Comet Biotech AS, Department of Nutrition, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
Front Toxicol. 2022 Oct 12;4:986318. doi: 10.3389/ftox.2022.986318. eCollection 2022.
The comet assay is a widely applied method for investigating genotoxicity of chemicals including engineered nanomaterials (NMs). A big challenge in hazard assessment of NMs is possible interference between the NMs and reagents or read-out of the test assay, leading to a risk of biased results. Here, we describe both the standard alkaline version of the comet assay with 12 mini-gels per slide for detection of DNA strand breaks and the enzyme-modified version that allows detection of oxidized DNA bases by applying lesion-specific endonucleases (e.g., formamidopyrimidine DNA glycosylase or endonuclease III). We highlight critical points that need to be taken into consideration when assessing the genotoxicity of NMs, as well as basic methodological considerations, such as the importance of carrying out physicochemical characterization of the NMs and investigating uptake and cytotoxicity. Also, experimental design-including treatment conditions, cell number, cell culture, format and volume of medium on the plate-is crucial and can have an impact on the results, especially when testing NMs. Toxicity of NMs depends upon physicochemical properties that change depending on the environment. To facilitate testing of numerous NMs with distinct modifications, the higher throughput miniaturized version of the comet assay is essential.
彗星试验是一种广泛应用于研究包括工程纳米材料(NMs)在内的化学物质遗传毒性的方法。纳米材料危害评估中的一个重大挑战是纳米材料与试剂之间可能存在干扰,或者测试分析的读数存在偏差,从而导致结果有偏差的风险。在此,我们描述了用于检测DNA链断裂的彗星试验标准碱性版本(每张载玻片有12个微型凝胶)以及酶修饰版本,该版本通过应用损伤特异性核酸内切酶(如甲酰胺嘧啶DNA糖基化酶或核酸内切酶III)来检测氧化的DNA碱基。我们强调了在评估纳米材料遗传毒性时需要考虑的关键点,以及基本的方法学考量,例如对纳米材料进行物理化学表征以及研究摄取和细胞毒性的重要性。此外,实验设计——包括处理条件、细胞数量、细胞培养、平板上培养基的形式和体积——至关重要,并且可能会对结果产生影响,尤其是在测试纳米材料时。纳米材料的毒性取决于其物理化学性质,而这些性质会因环境而异。为便于对众多具有不同修饰的纳米材料进行测试,彗星试验的高通量小型化版本至关重要。