Wamser-Nanney Rachel, Walker Hannah E
Department of Psychological Sciences, University of Missouri-St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
J Trauma Stress. 2023 Feb;36(1):17-30. doi: 10.1002/jts.22890. Epub 2022 Nov 1.
Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy (TF-CBT) is one of the leading interventions for trauma-exposed children and adolescents and is associated with significant improvements in a variety of trauma-related symptoms. Nonetheless, attrition from TF-CBT is quite common, and children who do not receive the full intervention may continue to suffer from trauma-related symptoms. Rates of premature termination have varied across studies, and to date, no meta-analyses have been conducted regarding dropout from TF-CBT. The objective of the present study was to conduct a meta-analysis of the rates of attrition from TF-CBT, as well as review factors related to premature termination from this intervention. A total of 22 studies were available for inclusion in this meta-analysis. The prevalence of attrition was 33.9% (95% CI [26.2%, 42.5%]) from 2,059 children receiving TF-CBT. Clinician-rated attrition was 38.5%, and 17.5% did not receive an adequate dose of TF-CBT (e.g., 12+ sessions). Further, the study type was related to differing rates of dropout, with randomized controlled trials having a much lower attrition rate. Regarding risk factors for premature termination, the emerging literature suggests that a child's age, racial-ethnic minority status, and symptom levels may evince some ties to attrition. Caregiver, family, therapist, and treatment factors remain underexplored in relation to premature termination; however, preliminary work suggests that lack of caregiver attendance and difficulty in the child-therapist relationship may be related to attrition. A substantial number of children prematurely terminate from TF-CBT, underscoring the need to better prevent dropout.
创伤聚焦认知行为疗法(TF-CBT)是针对遭受创伤的儿童和青少年的主要干预措施之一,与多种创伤相关症状的显著改善相关。尽管如此,TF-CBT治疗的脱落情况相当普遍,未接受完整干预的儿童可能会继续遭受创伤相关症状的困扰。不同研究中的提前终止治疗率各不相同,迄今为止,尚未对TF-CBT治疗的脱落情况进行荟萃分析。本研究的目的是对TF-CBT治疗的脱落率进行荟萃分析,并回顾与该干预措施提前终止相关的因素。本荟萃分析共纳入22项研究。接受TF-CBT治疗的2059名儿童中,脱落率为33.9%(95%置信区间[26.2%,42.5%])。临床医生评定的脱落率为38.5%,17.5%的儿童未接受足够剂量的TF-CBT治疗(如12次及以上疗程)。此外,研究类型与不同的脱落率相关,随机对照试验的脱落率要低得多。关于提前终止治疗的风险因素,新出现的文献表明,儿童的年龄、种族少数群体身份和症状水平可能与脱落存在一定关联。在提前终止治疗方面,照顾者、家庭、治疗师和治疗因素仍未得到充分研究;然而,初步研究表明,照顾者缺席以及儿童与治疗师关系困难可能与脱落有关。大量儿童提前终止TF-CBT治疗,这突出表明需要更好地预防治疗脱落。