McGuire Rosie, Meiser-Stedman Richard, Smith Patrick, Schmidt Davin, Bjornstad Gretchen, Bosworth Robyn, Clarke Timothy, Coombes Joe, Geijer Simpson Emma, Hudson Kristian, Oliveira Paula, Macleod John, McGovern Ruth, Stallard Paul, Wood Katie, Hiller Rachel M
Division of Psychology & Language Sciences, UCL, London, UK.
Department of Clinical Psychology and Psychological Therapies, University of East Anglia, Norwich, UK.
Br J Clin Psychol. 2025 Mar;64(1):63-85. doi: 10.1111/bjc.12471. Epub 2024 Jul 16.
Rates of PTSD are up to 12 times higher in care-experienced young people (CEYP) compared to their peers. Trauma-focused CBTs (tf-CBT) are the best-evidenced treatment for youth with PTSD, yet, in practice, CEYP often struggle to access this treatment. We worked alongside services to understand barriers and facilitators of the implementation of cognitive therapy for PTSD (a type of tf-CBT) to CEYP.
This was an active, open implementation trial.
We recruited 28 mental health teams across England, including general CAMHS, targeted CAMHS for CEYP and social care-based teams. From these teams, participants were 243 mental health professionals, from a wide variety of professional backgrounds. Following recruitment/intervention training, teams participated in rolling three monthly focus groups and individual interviews, to understand what helped and hindered implementation. Data were analysed using a framework analysis conducted using CFIR 2.0.
Almost half of the teams were able to implement, but only approximately one quarter with CEYP, specifically. Universal barriers that were discussed by almost all teams particularly highlighted service structures and poor resourcing as major barriers to delivery to CEYP, as well as the complexities of the young person and their network. Unique factors that differentiated teams who did and did not implement included commissioning practices, the culture of the team, leadership engagement and style, and the development of supervision structures.
Findings offer key considerations for mental health teams, service leads, commissioners and policy-makers to enhance delivery of best-evidenced mental health treatments like CT-PTSD, for CEYP.
与同龄人相比,有过照料经历的年轻人(CEYP)患创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的几率高出多达12倍。以创伤为重点的认知行为疗法(tf-CBT)是治疗患有PTSD的青少年的最有证据支持的疗法,然而,在实际中,CEYP往往难以获得这种治疗。我们与各服务机构合作,以了解对CEYP实施创伤后应激障碍认知疗法(一种tf-CBT)的障碍和促进因素。
这是一项积极的、开放式实施试验。
我们在英格兰招募了28个心理健康团队,包括普通儿童与青少年心理健康服务(CAMHS)、针对CEYP的针对性CAMHS以及基于社会护理的团队。来自这些团队的243名心理健康专业人员具有广泛的专业背景。在招募/干预培训之后,各团队参加了为期三个月的滚动焦点小组和个人访谈,以了解哪些因素有助于和阻碍实施。使用CFIR 2.0进行框架分析来分析数据。
几乎一半的团队能够实施,但具体而言,只有约四分之一的团队能够对CEYP实施。几乎所有团队都讨论过的普遍障碍特别强调了服务结构和资源匮乏是向CEYP提供服务的主要障碍,以及年轻人及其社交网络的复杂性。实施和未实施的团队之间存在差异的独特因素包括委托做法、团队文化、领导参与度和风格以及监督结构的发展。
研究结果为心理健康团队、服务负责人、委托方和政策制定者提供了关键考虑因素,以加强为CEYP提供像创伤后应激障碍认知疗法(CT-PTSD)这样有最佳证据支持的心理健康治疗。