Department of Psychiatry, Kinsmen Laboratory of Neurological Research, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Djavad Mowafaghian Centre for Brain Health, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Elife. 2022 Nov 3;11:e76506. doi: 10.7554/eLife.76506.
Volition - the sense of control or agency over one's voluntary actions - is widely recognized as the basis of both human subjective experience and natural behavior in nonhuman animals. Several human studies have found peaks in neural activity preceding voluntary actions, for example the readiness potential (RP), and some have shown upcoming actions could be decoded even before awareness. Others propose that random processes underlie and explain pre-movement neural activity. Here, we seek to address these issues by evaluating whether pre-movement neural activity in mice contains structure beyond that present in random neural activity. Implementing a self-initiated water-rewarded lever-pull paradigm in mice while recording widefield [Ca++] neural activity we find that cortical activity changes in variance seconds prior to movement and that upcoming lever pulls could be predicted between 3 and 5 s (or more in some cases) prior to movement. We found inhibition of motor cortex starting at approximately 5 s prior to lever pulls and activation of motor cortex starting at approximately 2 s prior to a random unrewarded left limb movement. We show that mice, like humans, are biased toward commencing self-initiated actions during specific phases of neural activity but that the pre-movement neural code changes over time in some mice and is widely distributed as behavior prediction improved when using all vs. single cortical areas. These findings support the presence of structured multi-second neural dynamics preceding self-initiated action beyond that expected from random processes. Our results also suggest that neural mechanisms underlying self-initiated action could be preserved between mice and humans.
意志——对自己自主行动的控制或代理感——被广泛认为是人类主观体验和非人类动物自然行为的基础。几项人类研究发现,在自愿行动之前,神经活动会出现峰值,例如准备电位(RP),有些研究甚至表明,在意识出现之前,即将发生的行动就可以被解码。其他人则提出,随机过程是运动前神经活动的基础和解释。在这里,我们通过评估老鼠运动前的神经活动是否包含随机神经活动之外的结构来解决这些问题。在老鼠中实施自发的水奖励杠杆拉动范式,同时记录宽场 [Ca++]神经活动,我们发现皮质活动在运动前几秒钟内变化,并且在运动前 3 到 5 秒(在某些情况下甚至更长)之间可以预测即将进行的杠杆拉动。我们发现,大约在进行杠杆拉动前 5 秒时,运动皮层开始抑制,大约在随机无奖励左肢运动前 2 秒时,运动皮层开始激活。我们表明,老鼠与人类一样,在神经活动的特定阶段倾向于开始自发的自主行动,但在某些老鼠中,运动前的神经编码会随着时间的推移而变化,并且当使用所有皮质区域而不是单个皮质区域时,行为预测会提高,因此神经编码的分布范围更广。这些发现支持在随机过程之外,存在自我启动动作之前的结构化多秒神经动力学。我们的研究结果还表明,老鼠和人类之间自我启动动作的神经机制可能是保守的。