Clinical Psychology, University of Lincoln, Lincoln, UK.
Psychol Psychother. 2023 Mar;96(1):223-248. doi: 10.1111/papt.12436. Epub 2022 Nov 7.
The present demand for child and adolescent mental health services exceeds the capacity for service provision. Greater research is required to understand the utility of accessible self-help interventions, such as mobile apps. This study sought to investigate whether use of a mental health app, underpinned by CBT, led to changes in psychological distress amongst adolescents. Mechanisms of change were examined, specifically whether changes are attributable to cognitive strategies.
This study utilised a multiple-baseline single-case experimental design, tracking variables across baseline and intervention phases. Surveys assessing participant experience were also administered.
Five participants with moderate-to-severe levels of psychological distress engaged with a CBT-based app over five weeks. Participants were recruited from both a well-being service and the general population. Supplementary weekly calls to participants offered clarification of app content.
A small overall effect of the intervention of psychological distress was evident; however, outcomes were dependent on the analysis conducted. The intervention appeared to promote an increase in use of adaptive cognitive strategies but not negative thinking styles. The CBT app did not promote changes in participant well-being. Participant feedback highlighted practical challenges of utilising the app.
The clinical benefits of app-based CBT were small, and a range of barriers to engagement were recognised. While further research is required, caution should be exercised in the interpretation of studies reporting on app effectiveness.
目前儿童和青少年心理健康服务的需求超过了服务提供能力。需要更多的研究来了解可及的自助干预措施(如移动应用程序)的效用。本研究旨在调查基于认知行为疗法的心理健康应用程序的使用是否会导致青少年心理困扰的变化。研究了变化的机制,特别是变化是否归因于认知策略。
本研究采用了多基线单案例实验设计,在基线和干预阶段跟踪变量。还进行了评估参与者体验的调查。
五名心理困扰程度为中度至重度的参与者在五周内使用基于认知行为疗法的应用程序。参与者是从幸福感服务和普通人群中招募的。每周向参与者提供补充电话,以澄清应用程序的内容。
干预对心理困扰的总体影响较小;然而,结果取决于所进行的分析。该干预似乎促进了适应性认知策略的使用增加,但没有促进消极思维模式的增加。CBT 应用程序并没有促进参与者幸福感的变化。参与者的反馈强调了使用应用程序的实际挑战。
基于应用程序的认知行为疗法的临床益处较小,并且认识到存在一系列参与障碍。虽然需要进一步的研究,但在解释报告应用程序有效性的研究时应谨慎。