Simon Judit, Wienand Dennis, Park A-La, Wippel Christoph, Mayer Susanne, Heilig Daniel, Laszewska Agata, Stelzer Ines, Goodwin Guy M, McDaid David
Department of Health Economics, Center of Public Health, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria; Ludwig Boltzmann Institute Applied Diagnostics, Vienna, Austria; Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, Warneford Hospital, Oxford, United Kingdom.
Department of Health Economics, Center of Public Health, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Eur Neuropsychopharmacol. 2023 Jan;66:14-27. doi: 10.1016/j.euroneuro.2022.10.001. Epub 2022 Nov 4.
Individuals with mental health disorders (MHDs) have worse physical health than the general population, utilise healthcare resources more frequently and intensively, incurring higher costs. We provide a first comprehensive overview and quantitative synthesis of literature on the magnitude of excess resource use and costs for those with MHDs and comorbid physical health conditions (PHCs). This systematic review (PROSPERO CRD42017075319) searched studies comparing resource use or costs of individuals with MHDs and comorbid PHCs versus individuals without comorbid conditions published between 2007 and 2021. We conducted narrative and quantitative syntheses, using random-effects meta-analyses to explore ranges of excess resource use and costs across care segments, comparing to MHD only, PHC only, or general population controls (GPC). Of 20,075 records, 228 and 100 were eligible for narrative and quantitative syntheses, respectively. Most studies were from the US, covered depression or schizophrenia, reporting endocrine/metabolic or circulatory comorbidities. Frequently investigated healthcare segments were inpatient, outpatient, emergency care and medications. Evidence on lost productivity, long-term and informal care was rare. Substantial differences exist between MHDs, with depressive disorder tending towards lower average excess resource use and cost estimates, while excess resource use ranges between +6% to +320% and excess costs between +14% to +614%. PHCs are major drivers of resource use and costs for individuals with MHDs, affecting care segments differently. Significant physical health gains and cost savings are potentially achievable through prevention, earlier identification, management and treatment, using more integrated care approaches. Current international evidence, however, is heterogeneous with limited geographical representativeness and comparability.
患有精神健康障碍(MHDs)的个体身体健康状况比普通人群更差,更频繁、更密集地使用医疗保健资源,从而产生更高的成本。我们首次全面概述并定量综合了有关MHDs患者以及合并身体健康状况(PHCs)患者资源过度使用程度和成本的文献。这项系统综述(PROSPERO CRD42017075319)检索了2007年至2021年间发表的比较MHDs合并PHCs个体与无合并症个体的资源使用或成本的研究。我们进行了叙述性和定量综合分析,使用随机效应荟萃分析来探讨各护理环节资源过度使用和成本的范围,并与仅患有MHDs、仅患有PHCs或普通人群对照(GPC)进行比较。在20,075条记录中,分别有228条和100条符合叙述性和定量综合分析的条件。大多数研究来自美国,涵盖抑郁症或精神分裂症,报告了内分泌/代谢或循环系统合并症。经常调查的医疗保健环节包括住院、门诊、急诊护理和药物治疗。关于生产力损失、长期护理和非正式护理的证据很少。不同的MHDs之间存在显著差异,抑郁症患者的平均资源过度使用和成本估计往往较低,而资源过度使用范围在+6%至+320%之间,成本过度范围在+14%至+614%之间。PHCs是MHDs患者资源使用和成本的主要驱动因素,对不同护理环节的影响不同。通过采用更综合的护理方法进行预防、早期识别、管理和治疗,有可能实现显著的身体健康改善和成本节约。然而,目前的国际证据存在异质性,地理代表性和可比性有限。