Asfour Mohammed, Menon Carlo, Jiang Xianta
Ubiquitous Computing and Machine Learning Lab, Department of Computer Science, Memorial University of Newfoundland and Labrador, St. John's, NL A1C 5S7, Canada.
Biomedical and Mobile Health Technology Laboratory, Department of Health Sciences and Technology, ETH Zürich, 8008 Zürich, Switzerland.
Bioengineering (Basel). 2022 Nov 2;9(11):634. doi: 10.3390/bioengineering9110634.
Gesture recognition using surface electromyography (sEMG) serves many applications, from human-machine interfaces to prosthesis control. Many features have been adopted to enhance recognition accuracy. However, studies mostly compare features under a prechosen feature window size or a classifier, biased to a specific application. The bias is evident in the reported accuracy drop, around 10%, from offline gesture recognition in experiment settings to real-time clinical environment studies. This paper explores the feature-classifier pairing compatibility for sEMG. We demonstrate that it is the primary determinant of gesture recognition accuracy under various window sizes and normalization ranges, thus removing application bias. The proposed pairing ranking provides a guideline for choosing the proper feature or classifier in future research. For instance, random forest (RF) performed best, with a mean accuracy of around 74.0%; however, it was optimal with the mean absolute value feature (MAV), giving 86.8% accuracy. Additionally, our ranking showed that the proper pairing enables low-computational models to surpass complex ones. The Histogram feature with linear discriminant analysis classifier (HIST-LDA) was the top pair with 88.6% accuracy. We also concluded that a 1250 ms window and a (-1, 1) signal normalization were the optimal procedures for gesture recognition on the used dataset.
使用表面肌电图(sEMG)的手势识别有许多应用,从人机接口到假肢控制。人们采用了许多特征来提高识别准确率。然而,大多数研究都是在预先选择的特征窗口大小或分类器下比较特征,偏向于特定应用。这种偏向在报告的准确率下降中很明显,从实验设置中的离线手势识别到实时临床环境研究,准确率下降约10%。本文探讨了sEMG的特征-分类器配对兼容性。我们证明,在各种窗口大小和归一化范围内,它是手势识别准确率的主要决定因素,从而消除了应用偏向。所提出的配对排名为未来研究中选择合适的特征或分类器提供了指导。例如,随机森林(RF)表现最佳,平均准确率约为74.0%;然而,它与平均绝对值特征(MAV)搭配时最优,准确率为86.8%。此外,我们的排名表明,合适的配对能使低计算量模型超越复杂模型。具有线性判别分析分类器的直方图特征(HIST-LDA)是最佳配对,准确率为88.6%。我们还得出结论,对于所使用的数据集,1250毫秒的窗口和(-1, 1)的信号归一化是手势识别的最优过程。