Medical Education Center, Faculty of Medicine, Osaka Medical and Pharmaceutical University, Osaka, Japan.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2022 Nov 11;101(45):e31392. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000031392.
The present study examined the impact of age on medical student repeat-year experience and performance outcomes on the objective structured clinical examination (OSCE), Clinical Clerkship (CC), and other relevant examinations in the Japanese medical school system. This retrospective analysis examined the number of students with repeat-years and the years required to graduate, stratifying students by the age they entered medical school (Younger: within 4 years of high school graduation; Older: 5 or more years after high school graduation). Scores of the Pre-CC OSCE, Computer-based testing (CBT), CC performance, CC integrative test, and graduation exams were compared among those graduating from our medical school between 2018 and 2020, and examined correlations between student age and performance outcomes. From 2018 to 2020, 328 medical students graduated. Of these, 283 had entered within 4 years of high school graduation (Younger), while 45 did so 5 or more years after high school graduation (Older). The number of repeat-years did not differ significantly between groups. The average number of years required to graduate was slightly higher for the Older group and the Younger group scored significantly higher on the CC integrative test. No significant differences were found for the remaining tests. These results suggest that older medical students in general show no significant inferiority in their performance of most clinical skills and competencies relative to younger students in Japan.
本研究考察了年龄对日本医学教育体系中学生复读年数和客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)、临床实习(CC)及其他相关考试成绩的影响。该回顾性分析考察了复读学生的数量和毕业所需的年限,将学生按入学年龄分为两类:年龄较小(高中毕业后 4 年内)和年龄较大(高中毕业后 5 年或以上)。比较了 2018 年至 2020 年期间从我校毕业的学生在 CC 前 OSCE、基于计算机的测试(CBT)、CC 表现、CC 综合考试和毕业考试中的成绩,并考察了学生年龄与成绩之间的相关性。2018 年至 2020 年期间,共有 328 名医学生毕业。其中,283 人入学时间在高中毕业后 4 年内(年轻组),45 人入学时间在高中毕业后 5 年或以上(年长组)。两组之间复读年数没有显著差异。年长组平均毕业所需年限略长,而年轻组在 CC 综合考试中的得分显著更高。其余考试未发现显著差异。这些结果表明,与日本年轻学生相比,年龄较大的医学生在大多数临床技能和能力方面的表现并没有明显劣势。