Zhang Dafang, Earp Brandon E
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, United States.
Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, United States.
J Hand Microsurg. 2020 Nov 16;14(4):304-307. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1721171. eCollection 2022 Oct.
The objective of this study was to assess the usefulness of Instagram posts for users seeking information about common hand conditions. An internet-based study was performed of the top 200 trending posts on Instagram for each of the tags #carpaltunnel and #triggerfinger. The trending position (1 through 200), number of likes (for all posts), and number of views (for video posts only) were recorded. Each post was assessed to determine whether it would be useful for a user seeking medical information. Useful and not useful posts were further classified into thematic categories. Useful posts comprised only 21% of #carpaltunnel posts and 12% of #triggerfinger posts. #carpaltunnel had a significantly higher proportion of useful posts than #triggerfinger. For both #carpaltunnel and #trigger finger, useful posts were not associated with trending position or number of likes. Useful posts commonly provided a clinical image or an anatomical diagram. Posts that were not useful were generally irrelevant to the hand condition, but a minority provided information not supported by evidence or were solely advertising material. Hand surgery patients can be educated that, in its current form, Instagram is not a source of useful information about common hand conditions.
本研究的目的是评估Instagram上的帖子对寻求常见手部疾病信息的用户的有用性。
针对#腕管综合征和#扳机指这两个标签,对Instagram上排名前200的热门帖子进行了一项基于互联网的研究。记录了热门排名(1至200)、点赞数(所有帖子)和观看次数(仅视频帖子)。对每个帖子进行评估,以确定其对寻求医疗信息的用户是否有用。有用和无用的帖子进一步分为主题类别。
有用的帖子在#腕管综合征帖子中仅占21%,在#扳机指帖子中占12%。#腕管综合征有用帖子的比例明显高于#扳机指。对于#腕管综合征和#扳机指,有用的帖子与热门排名或点赞数均无关联。有用的帖子通常会提供临床图片或解剖图。无用的帖子通常与手部疾病无关,但少数帖子提供的信息缺乏证据支持或纯粹是广告材料。
应告知手部手术患者,就目前的形式而言,Instagram并非获取常见手部疾病有用信息的来源。