Center for Geriatric Medicine, Heidelberg University Hospital, AGAPLESION Bethanien Hospital Heidelberg, Rohrbacher Strasse 149, 69126, Heidelberg, Germany.
Department of General Practice and Health Services Research, Heidelberg University Hospital, Im Neuenheimer Feld 130.3, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany.
BMC Geriatr. 2022 Nov 19;22(1):879. doi: 10.1186/s12877-022-03573-8.
Delirium is a common condition in elderly inpatients. Health care professionals play a crucial role in recognizing delirium, initiating preventive measures and implementing a multicomponent treatment strategy. Yet, delirium often goes unrecognized in clinical routine. Nurses take an important role in preventing and managing delirium. This study assesses clinical reasoning of nurses using case vignettes to explore their competences in recognizing, preventing and managing delirium.
The study was conducted as an online survey. The questionnaire was based on five case vignettes presenting cases of acutely ill older patients with different subtypes of delirium or diseases with overlapping symptoms. In a first step, case vignettes were developed and validated through a multidisciplinary expert panel. Scoring of response options were summed up to a Geriatric Delirium Competence Questionnaire (GDCQ) score including recognition and management tasks The questionnaire was made available online. Descriptive analyses and group comparisons explores differences between nurses from different settings. Factors explaining variance in participants' score were evaluated using correlations and linear regression models.
The questionnaire demonstrated good content validity and high reliability (kappa = 0.79). The final sample consisted of 115 nurses. Five hundred seventy-five case vignettes with an accuracy of 0.71 for the correct recognition of delirium presence or absence were solved. Nurses recognized delirium best in cases describing hyperactive delirium (79%) while hypoactive delirium was recognized least (44%). Nurses from geriatric and internal medicine departments had significantly higher GDCQ-score than the other subgroups. Management tasks were correctly identified by most participants.
Overall, nurses' competence regarding hypoactive delirium should be strengthened. The online questionnaire might facilitate targeting training opportunities to nurses' competence.
谵妄是老年住院患者的常见病症。医护人员在识别谵妄、启动预防措施和实施多组分治疗策略方面发挥着至关重要的作用。然而,在临床常规中,谵妄常常未被识别。护士在预防和管理谵妄方面发挥着重要作用。本研究使用病例情景评估护士的临床推理,以探讨他们在识别、预防和管理谵妄方面的能力。
该研究采用在线调查的方式进行。问卷基于五个病例情景,呈现了不同类型谵妄或具有重叠症状的疾病的急性老年患者的病例。在第一步中,通过多学科专家小组开发并验证了病例情景。对反应选项的评分汇总到一个老年谵妄能力问卷(GDCQ)中,其中包括识别和管理任务。问卷在线提供。描述性分析和组间比较探讨了来自不同环境的护士之间的差异。使用相关性和线性回归模型评估了解释参与者得分差异的因素。
问卷表现出良好的内容有效性和高度可靠性(kappa=0.79)。最终样本由 115 名护士组成。解决了 575 个病例情景,正确识别出谵妄存在或不存在的准确性为 0.71。护士在描述活跃型谵妄的病例中对谵妄的识别最好(79%),而在描述不活跃型谵妄的病例中识别率最低(44%)。老年医学和内科部门的护士的 GDCQ 得分明显高于其他亚组。大多数参与者正确识别了管理任务。
总体而言,护士在不活跃型谵妄方面的能力应得到加强。在线问卷可能有助于针对护士的能力提供培训机会。