Corduff Niamh
Cosmetic Refinement Clinic, Geelong, Victoria, Australia.
Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2022 Nov 16;10(11):e4631. doi: 10.1097/GOX.0000000000004631. eCollection 2022 Nov.
A retrospective review of patients who switched from onabotulinumtoxinA (onaA) and/or abobotulinumtoxinA (aboA) to incobotulinumtoxinA (incoA) found anecdotal reports of differences in "feel," including a "lighter" feel or treatment-associated tightness. We surveyed the frequency of these sensations as an initial proof of concept of toxin proprioception among our patients who switched toxins.
Seventy-nine patients who had past facial aesthetic treatments with more than one botulinum toxin A (BoNT/A) formulation completed a questionnaire on their experience of treatment-associated sensations, including stiffness or a frozen feeling.
Treatment-associated sensations of tightness (47.3%), headache (41.8%), heaviness (38.2%), feeling frozen (29.1%), stiffness (20.0%), and weakness (20.0%) were reported by 55 of 79 patients. Furthermore, 78.2% of 55 patients noted an interformulation sensory difference. Of 79 patients surveyed, 68.4% of onaA-treated patients associated sensations with onaA, 39.1% of aboA-treated patients associated sensations with aboA, and 12.2% of incoA-treated patients associated sensations with incoA.
Some patients reported a different feel between toxins, and the difference in frequency of treatment-associated sensation varies between the different formulations used. Given the fine coordination of facial expressive muscles, we suspect that associated proprioceptive afferents are involved. Our findings confirm that post-toxin treatment-associated sensations can be detected by some patients, and this is likely due to the variations between the formulations. Failing to advise patients of this before switching formulations may cause a misperception that the treatment is not working well or that its effect has worn off prematurely, and some patients may consider switching formulations to reduce these conscious proprioceptive sensations.
一项对从注射用A型肉毒毒素(onaA)和/或A型肉毒杆菌毒素(aboA)转换为注射用A型肉毒毒素(incoA)的患者的回顾性研究发现,有轶事报道称在“感觉”上存在差异,包括“更轻”的感觉或与治疗相关的紧绷感。我们调查了这些感觉的发生频率,作为我们转换毒素的患者中毒素本体感觉概念验证的初步证据。
79名曾使用过不止一种A型肉毒杆菌毒素(BoNT/A)制剂进行过面部美学治疗的患者完成了一份关于他们与治疗相关感觉体验的问卷,包括僵硬或僵硬感。
79名患者中有55名报告了与治疗相关的紧绷感(47.3%)、头痛(41.8%)、沉重感(38.2%)、僵硬感(29.1%)、僵硬(20.0%)和虚弱感(20.0%)。此外,55名患者中有78.2%注意到不同制剂之间的感觉差异。在接受调查的79名患者中,68.4%接受onaA治疗的患者将感觉与onaA相关联,39.1%接受aboA治疗的患者将感觉与aboA相关联,12.2%接受incoA治疗的患者将感觉与incoA相关联。
一些患者报告了不同毒素之间感觉不同,并且与治疗相关感觉的频率差异在所用的不同制剂之间有所不同。鉴于面部表情肌肉的精细协调,我们怀疑相关的本体感觉传入神经参与其中。我们的研究结果证实,一些患者可以检测到毒素治疗后的相关感觉,这可能是由于制剂之间的差异。在转换制剂之前未告知患者这一点可能会导致误解,认为治疗效果不佳或其效果过早消失,并且一些患者可能会考虑更换制剂以减少这些有意识的本体感觉。