Department of General Surgery, Peking University First Hospital, Peking University, Beijing, China.
Front Public Health. 2022 Nov 3;10:1000338. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.1000338. eCollection 2022.
Anal fissure is a common colorectal disease impacting patients' life quality with high incidence. Social media platforms are becoming a kind of health information source nowadays. This study aims to evaluate and compare the quality of anal fissure-related videos on TikTok and YouTube.
One hundred videos were sourced from TikTok and YouTube, respectively and videos were screened further. The completeness of six types of content within the videos is assessed, including the definition of disease, symptoms, risk factors, evaluation, management and outcomes. Finally, the DISCERN instrument, Patient Education Materials Assessment Tool and Global Quality scale are used to assess video display quality and content. A correlation analysis is undertaken considering the video features, DISCERN, PEMAT and GQS scores.
Physicians and non-profit organizations contributed almost all video content among selected videos. A statistically significant correlation between DISCERN classification and duration, PEMAT understandability, PEMAT actionability and GQS scores is recorded. DISCERN total scores were significantly positively correlated with video duration, PEMAT understandability, PEMAT actionability and GQS scores. GQS scores were significantly positively correlated with duration, PEMAT understandability and PEMAT actionability scores. For content, the videos mainly described management and symptoms while containing limited information on the disease evaluation, and outcomes.
The sources of uploaders on YouTube are more diverse than TikTok, and the quality of videos is also relatively higher on YouTube. Even so, the video quality of the two platforms still needs to be further improved. Health information without integrity, reliability and practicability impacts patients' disease perception and health-seeking behavior, leading to serious consequences. Much effort must be taken to improve the quality of videos regarding anal fissures on the two platforms, which will facilitate the development of public health education on this issue.
肛裂是一种常见的肛肠疾病,发病率高,严重影响患者的生活质量。社交媒体平台如今已成为一种健康信息来源。本研究旨在评估和比较 TikTok 和 YouTube 上与肛裂相关的视频质量。
分别从 TikTok 和 YouTube 上获取 100 个视频,并对视频进行筛选。评估视频中包含的六种类型内容的完整性,包括疾病定义、症状、危险因素、评估、管理和结果。最后,使用 DISCERN 工具、患者教育材料评估工具和全球质量量表来评估视频显示质量和内容。考虑视频特征、DISCERN、PEMAT 和 GQS 评分,进行相关性分析。
在选择的视频中,医生和非营利组织几乎提供了所有视频内容。DISCERN 分类与视频时长、PEMAT 可理解性、PEMAT 可操作性和 GQS 评分之间存在统计学显著相关性。DISCERN 总分与视频时长、PEMAT 可理解性、PEMAT 可操作性和 GQS 评分呈显著正相关。GQS 评分与视频时长、PEMAT 可理解性和 PEMAT 可操作性评分呈显著正相关。就内容而言,视频主要描述了管理和症状,而对疾病评估和结果的信息有限。
YouTube 上上传者的来源比 TikTok 更多样化,视频质量也相对较高。即便如此,两个平台的视频质量仍需进一步提高。不完整、不可靠和不切实际的健康信息会影响患者对疾病的认知和寻求健康的行为,导致严重后果。必须努力提高两个平台上关于肛裂的视频质量,这将有助于该问题的公共卫生教育的发展。