Department of Orthodontics, Istanbul Aydin University, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2022 Oct;123(5):e349-e354. doi: 10.1016/j.jormas.2022.04.009. Epub 2022 Apr 22.
The aim of this study was to evaluate and compare orthodontic videos uploaded to YouTube and TikTok, the two most popular video sharing platforms, and to determine which of these platforms has more reliable and higher quality videos.
YouTube (www.YouTube.com) and Tiktok (www.tiktok.com) was searched for two search-terms: "Orthodontics" and "Orthodontic Treatment". Reliability and quality of the first 120 videos for each search-term was evaluated by social media video content evaluation tools: Global Quality Score (GQS) and Reliability Score (modified DISCERN tool).
While YouTube videos were more informative or sharing patient experiences, TikTok videos were almost purely entertainment oriented. Tiktok videos had lower reliability. YouTube videos were rated of higher quality than Tiktok videos. GQS mean values for Youtube and TikTok were 2.90 ± 1.35 and 2.23 ± 1.08 respectively; and reliability (DISCERN) values were 2.42 ± 1.70 and 1.27 ± 1.48 respectively. GQS median values for Youtube and TikTok were 3 and 2 respectively; and reliability (DISCERN) values were 2 and 1 respectively. Most of the uploaders in both platforms were professionals.
Neither YouTube videos nor Tiktok videos were found to be reliable or of good quality. Videos on YouTube were higher quality and more reliable than videos on TikTok. However, YouTube videos also contained unreliable information.
本研究旨在评估和比较上传至 YouTube 和 TikTok(两个最受欢迎的视频分享平台)的正畸视频,并确定这两个平台中哪个平台拥有更可靠且更高质量的视频。
在 YouTube(www.YouTube.com)和 TikTok(www.tiktok.com)上搜索两个搜索词:“Orthodontics”和“Orthodontic Treatment”。使用社交媒体视频内容评估工具(全球质量评分(GQS)和可靠性评分(改良的 DISCERN 工具)评估前 120 个每个搜索词视频的可靠性和质量。
YouTube 视频更具信息性或分享患者经验,而 TikTok 视频几乎完全是娱乐性的。TikTok 视频的可靠性较低。YouTube 视频的质量评分高于 TikTok 视频。YouTube 和 TikTok 的 GQS 平均值分别为 2.90±1.35 和 2.23±1.08;可靠性(DISCERN)值分别为 2.42±1.70 和 1.27±1.48。YouTube 和 TikTok 的 GQS 中位数分别为 3 和 2;可靠性(DISCERN)值分别为 2 和 1。两个平台的大多数上传者都是专业人士。
YouTube 视频和 TikTok 视频都不可靠或质量不高。YouTube 上的视频质量和可靠性均高于 TikTok 上的视频。然而,YouTube 视频也包含不可靠的信息。