Department of Biomedical Imaging and Image-Guided Therapy, Medical University of Vienna, Währinger Gürtel 18-20, A-1090 Vienna, Austria.
Department of Radiology, UMass Memorial Medical Center and University of Massachusetts Chan Medical School, Worcester, MA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2023 May;220(5):672-680. doi: 10.2214/AJR.22.28515. Epub 2022 Dec 7.
Prior work has shown improved image quality for photon-counting detector (PCD) CT of the lungs compared with energy-integrating detector CT. A paucity of the literature has compared PCD CT of the lungs using different reconstruction parameters. The purpose of this study is to the compare the image quality of ultra-high-resolution (UHR) PCD CT image sets of the lungs that were reconstructed using different kernels and slice thicknesses. This retrospective study included 29 patients (17 women and 12 men; median age, 56 years) who underwent noncontrast chest CT from February 15, 2022, to March 15, 2022, by use of a commercially available PCD CT scanner. All acquisitions used UHR mode (1024 × 1024 matrix). Nine image sets were reconstructed for all combinations of three sharp kernels (BI56, BI60, and BI64) and three slice thicknesses (0.2, 0.4, and 1.0 mm). Three radiologists independently reviewed reconstructions for measures of visualization of pulmonary anatomic structures and pathologies; reader assessments were pooled. Reconstructions were compared with the clinical reference reconstruction (obtained using the BI64 kernel and a 1.0-mm slice thickness [BI64]). The median difference in the number of bronchial divisions identified versus the clinical reference reconstruction was higher for reconstructions with BI64 (0.5), BI60 (0.3), BI64 (0.5), and BI60 (0.2) (all < .05). The median bronchial wall sharpness versus the clinical reference reconstruction was higher for reconstructions with BI64 (0.3) and BI64 (0.3) and was lower for BI56 (-0.7) and BI56 (-0.3) (all < .05). Median pulmonary fissure sharpness versus the clinical reference reconstruction was higher for reconstructions with BI64 (0.3), BI60 (0.3), BI56 (0.5), BI64 (0.5), BI60 (0.5), and BI56 (0.3) (all < .05). Median pulmonary vessel sharpness versus the clinical reference reconstruction was lower for reconstructions with BI56 (-0.3), BI60 (-0.3), BI56 (-0.7), BI64 (-0.7), BI60 (-0.7), and BI56 (-0.7). Median lung nodule conspicuity versus the clinical reference reconstruction was lower for reconstructions with BI56 (-0.3) and BI56 (-0.3) (both < .05). Median conspicuity of all other pathologies versus the clinical reference reconstruction was lower for reconstructions with BI561.0 mm (-0.3), BI56 (-0.3), BI64 (-0.3), BI60 (-0.3), and BI56 (-0.3). Other comparisons among reconstructions were not significant (all > .05). Only the reconstruction using BI64 yielded improved bronchial division identification and bronchial wall and pulmonary fissure sharpness without a loss in pulmonary vessel sharpness or conspicuity of nodules or other pathologies. The findings of this study may guide protocol optimization for UHR PCD CT of the lungs.
先前的工作表明,与能量积分探测器 CT 相比,光子计数探测器 (PCD) CT 对肺部的图像质量有了改善。然而,关于使用不同重建参数的肺部 PCD CT 比较的文献却很少。本研究的目的是比较使用不同内核和切片厚度重建的超高分辨率 (UHR) PCD CT 肺部图像组的图像质量。这项回顾性研究包括 29 名患者(17 名女性和 12 名男性;中位年龄为 56 岁),他们在 2022 年 2 月 15 日至 3 月 15 日期间使用商业可用的 PCD CT 扫描仪进行了非对比性胸部 CT 检查。所有采集均采用 UHR 模式(1024×1024 矩阵)。对于三种锐利内核(BI56、BI60 和 BI64)和三种切片厚度(0.2、0.4 和 1.0mm)的所有组合,重建了 9 个图像组。三位放射科医生独立评估了肺解剖结构和病变的可视化测量指标;读者评估结果被汇总。将重建与临床参考重建(使用 BI64 内核和 1.0mm 切片厚度 [BI64] 获得)进行比较。与临床参考重建相比,BI64(0.5)、BI60(0.3)、BI64(0.5)和 BI60(0.2)重建中识别的支气管分支数量差异的中位数更高(均 <.05)。与临床参考重建相比,BI64(0.3)和 BI64(0.3)重建的支气管壁锐利度中位数更高,BI56(-0.7)和 BI56(-0.3)重建的锐利度中位数更低(均 <.05)。与临床参考重建相比,BI64(0.3)、BI60(0.3)、BI56(0.5)、BI64(0.5)、BI60(0.5)和 BI56(0.3)重建的肺裂锐利度中位数更高(均 <.05)。与临床参考重建相比,BI56(-0.3)、BI60(-0.3)、BI56(-0.7)、BI64(-0.7)、BI60(-0.7)和 BI56(-0.7)重建的肺血管锐利度中位数更低。与临床参考重建相比,BI56(-0.3)和 BI56(-0.3)重建的肺结节对比噪声比中位数更低(均 <.05)。与临床参考重建相比,BI561.0mm(-0.3)、BI56(-0.3)、BI64(-0.3)、BI60(-0.3)和 BI56(-0.3)重建的所有其他病变的对比噪声比中位数均较低。重建之间的其他比较没有显著差异(均 >.05)。只有使用 BI64 的重建才能提高支气管分支的识别率以及支气管壁和肺裂的锐利度,而不会降低肺血管的锐利度或结节或其他病变的显著性。本研究的结果可能有助于优化肺部超高分辨率 PCD CT 的协议。