School of Marxism, Southeast University, Nanjing 210037, China.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Dec 13;19(24):16704. doi: 10.3390/ijerph192416704.
Actor-network theory, which emerged from science and technology studies in the 1980s, regards everything in the social and ecological systems as a continuous result of the network of relations where they are located. Social-ecological resilience, with its origins in systems ecology, focuses on the non-linear changing dynamics of social-ecological systems and their governance. Among them, social-ecological resilience study integrates different disciplines, backgrounds, and themes, which inevitably leads to the vagueness of its concept. Both actor-network theory and social-ecological resilience emphasize human-nature relationships and view social-ecological systems as dynamic and unpredictable "networks". Therefore, this paper explored the potential conceptual or theoretical underpinnings that actor-network theory can provide in social-ecological resilience through interdisciplinary research. Specifically, a semi-structured interview was conducted with 30 fishing households from Chang-shan Archipelago in Northeastern China. The obtained interview data were analyzed through thematic analysis, and three main themes were generated, including "heterogeneous networks", "agency", and "translation", which facilitated a reconceptualization of the three components of social-ecological resilience, namely, "linked social-ecological systems", "changing dynamics" and "the ability to maintain resilience", and also provided a new theoretical perspective on the adaptive governance of social-ecological systems.
行动者网络理论产生于 20 世纪 80 年代的科学技术研究,它将社会和生态系统中的一切都视为它们所处的关系网络的连续结果。社会生态弹性起源于系统生态学,侧重于社会生态系统及其治理的非线性变化动态。其中,社会生态弹性研究整合了不同的学科、背景和主题,这不可避免地导致了其概念的模糊性。行动者网络理论和社会生态弹性都强调人与自然的关系,并将社会生态系统视为动态和不可预测的“网络”。因此,本文通过跨学科研究探索了行动者网络理论在社会生态弹性中可能提供的潜在概念或理论基础。具体来说,对来自中国东北长山群岛的 30 户渔民进行了半结构化访谈。通过主题分析对获得的访谈数据进行了分析,生成了三个主要主题,包括“异质网络”、“能动性”和“翻译”,这有助于重新概念化社会生态弹性的三个组成部分,即“关联的社会生态系统”、“变化的动态”和“维持弹性的能力”,并为社会生态系统的适应性治理提供了一个新的理论视角。