Department of Information and Communication Technologies, Centre for e-Health, University of Agder, Grimstad, Norway.
Department of Health and Nursing Sciences, Centre for e-Health, University of Agder, Grimstad, Norway.
Int J Med Inform. 2023 Feb;170:104964. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2022.104964. Epub 2022 Dec 12.
Exploitation of telehealth in prenatal care has the potential to reduce the access barrier to care and empower women to participate in their own care. This review aims to assess the practical implications of virtual prenatal care and identify the needs and experiences associated with it.
A systematic literature review was conducted in four electronic databases: PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus, and Cochrane. The keywords used were "pregnancy", "virtual visit", "prenatal", and others. The search included all relevant studies published from 2011 to 2021 written in English. Articles mentioning virtual prenatal care incorporating synchronous communication between pregnant women and health care professionals were included. Those unrelated to prenatal care or employing asynchronous means of virtual care were excluded. The review was structured following the PRISMA guidelines. Different quality appraisal methods such as JBI, CASP, NOS, and Cochrane were used to assess the methodological quality of the literature. The data were then analyzed based on the categorization of the studies.
Overall, 2863 articles were identified, of which 19 met the inclusion criteria after removing duplicates, screening of abstracts, and full text-four articles identified from hand-searching were incorporated, making a total of 23 eligible articles for the review. The studies' findings revealed the preference for implementing cost-effective virtual care based on the resource set, technological literacy, and consistent accessibility. Further, no significant differences in clinical outcomes were observed between two modes of care, virtual and in-person. The higher satisfaction by pregnant women and healthcare professionals indicated the continuity of the care. In addition, the hybrid model of virtual prenatal care integrated with traditional in-person care was acceptable to both low-risk and high-risk pregnant women. Virtual prenatal care substantially reduced travel time and absences from work, drops in clinic wait time and no-show rate, limited the risk of exposure during a pandemic, and increased self-accountability.
Virtual prenatal care offers predominant advantages over in-person when it is carefully designed with the inclusion of pregnant women and healthcare professionals' needs. Evidence showed that providing adequate technology training, proper instruction, and guidelines for initial setup and assurance of a reliable and accessible system is vital in increasing access to care.
在产前保健中利用远程医疗有可能减少获得保健的障碍,并使妇女能够参与自身保健。本综述旨在评估虚拟产前护理的实际影响,并确定与之相关的需求和经验。
在四个电子数据库中进行了系统文献综述:PubMed、Web of Science、Scopus 和 Cochrane。使用的关键词是“妊娠”、“虚拟访问”、“产前”等。检索包括 2011 年至 2021 年期间以英文发表的所有相关研究。纳入了提到采用同步通信方式使孕妇和医疗保健专业人员进行虚拟产前护理的文章。排除了与产前保健无关或采用异步虚拟保健方式的文章。综述遵循 PRISMA 指南进行。使用不同的质量评估方法,如 JBI、CASP、NOS 和 Cochrane,评估文献的方法学质量。然后根据研究的分类对数据进行分析。
总共确定了 2863 篇文章,其中 19 篇在去除重复项、摘要筛选和全文筛选后符合纳入标准,另外从手工检索中纳入了 4 篇文章,共有 23 篇符合综述要求的文章。研究结果表明,根据资源集、技术素养和一致性可及性,更倾向于实施具有成本效益的虚拟护理。此外,虚拟护理和亲自护理两种模式的临床结局没有显著差异。孕妇和医疗保健专业人员的满意度较高表明护理的连续性。此外,虚拟产前护理与传统的亲自护理相结合的混合模式对低风险和高风险孕妇都是可以接受的。虚拟产前护理大大减少了旅行时间和工作缺勤,降低了诊所等待时间和未到诊率,限制了大流行期间的暴露风险,并增加了自我责任感。
虚拟产前护理在精心设计并纳入孕妇和医疗保健专业人员的需求时,比亲自护理具有明显优势。证据表明,提供足够的技术培训、适当的指导以及初始设置的指南和可靠、可及系统的保证,对于增加获得保健的机会至关重要。