Department of Medical Education, Mie University Graduate School of Medicine, Tsu, Japan.
Department of Pediatrics, Daido Hospital, Nagoya, Japan.
Int J Med Educ. 2022 Dec 26;13:322-334. doi: 10.5116/ijme.6399.dee1.
This study aimed to assess the perception of PBL among Japanese medical students.
Learning effects and challenges of PBL from the students' viewpoint were assessed with an exploratory sequential mixed method. Focus group discussions followed by thematic analysis were conducted with 27 students and residents. Then a questionnaire survey was carried out. A total of 119 out of 258 students (46.1%) responded. The results from 24 questions were analyzed with a residual analysis.
Thematic analysis extracted 14 themes from four discussion topics. The participants in focus group discussion regarded the PBL program as a better learning method than lectures. But some key phrases on the challenge of social interaction, including reluctance to actively discuss and collaborate with unfamiliar peers, were found. The questionnaire survey revealed a significantly lower adjusted standardized residual (ASR) for the positive response in five of six questions in the category of social interaction; improvement of communication skills (ASR = -3.303, n = 118, p < .001), enhancement of responsibility at group discussions (ASR = -2.078, n = 119, p = .038), building social networking (ASR = -3.006, n = 119, p = .003), becoming to sympathize with patients (ASR = -2.449, n = 119, p = .014) and understanding social aspects of clinical practice (ASR = -5.790, n = 119, p < .001). Conclusion: The Japanese medical students perceived PBL as an effective learning strategy. However, they had a problem with social interactions.
本研究旨在评估日本医学生对 PBL 的看法。
采用探索性序贯混合方法评估学生从 PBL 中获得的学习效果和挑战。对 27 名学生和住院医师进行了焦点小组讨论和主题分析,然后进行了问卷调查。共有 258 名学生中的 119 名(46.1%)做出了回应。对 24 个问题的结果进行了残差分析。
主题分析从四个讨论主题中提取了 14 个主题。焦点小组讨论的参与者认为 PBL 课程比讲座更有利于学习。但在社会互动的挑战方面,发现了一些关键短语,包括不愿意积极与不熟悉的同龄人讨论和合作。问卷调查显示,在社会互动这一类的六个问题中有五个问题的积极回答的调整标准化残差(ASR)显著较低;沟通技巧的提高(ASR=-3.303,n=118,p<.001)、增强小组讨论中的责任感(ASR=-2.078,n=119,p=0.038)、建立社交网络(ASR=-3.006,n=119,p=0.003)、对患者表示同情(ASR=-2.449,n=119,p=0.014)和理解临床实践的社会方面(ASR=-5.790,n=119,p<.001)。结论:日本医学生认为 PBL 是一种有效的学习策略。然而,他们在社会互动方面存在问题。