Ndayishimiye Costase, Lopes Henrique, Middleton John
Association of Schools of Public Health in the European Region (ASPHER), 1150 Brussels, Belgium.
Health Economics and Social Security Department, Jagiellonian University Medical College, 8 Skawińska, 31-066 Krakow, Poland.
Health Technol (Berl). 2023;13(2):273-284. doi: 10.1007/s12553-023-00725-7. Epub 2023 Jan 6.
This scoping review compiled information concerning digital health technologies (DHTs) evolution to support primary health care (PHC) during COVID-19 and lessons for the future of PHC. The identified literature was published during the COVID-19 peak years (2019-2021), retrieved from PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar, as well as hand searched on the internet. Predefined inclusion criteria were used, thematic analysis was applied, and reporting followed the PRISMA for Scoping Reviews. A total of 46 studies were included in the final synthesis (40 articles, one book, two book chapters, one working paper, and two technical reports). These studies scrutinized various aspects of DHTs, entailing 19 types of DHTs with 20 areas of use that can be compressed into five bigger PHC functions: general PHC service delivery (teleconsultations, e-diagnosis, e-prescription, etc.); behavior promotion and digital health literacy (e.g., combating vaccine hesitancy); surveillance functions; vaccination and drugs; and enhancing system decision-making for proper follow-up of ongoing PHC interventions during COVID-19. DHTs have the potential to solve some of the problems that have plagued us even prior to COVID-19. Therefore, this study uses a forward-looking viewpoint to further stimulate the use of evidence-based DHT, making it more inclusive, educative, and satisfying to people's needs, both under normal conditions and during outbreaks. More research with narrowed research questions is needed, with a particular emphasis on quality assurance in the use of DHTs, technical aspects (standards for digital health tools, infrastructure, and platforms), and financial perspectives (payment for digital health services and adoption incentives).
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12553-023-00725-7.
本范围综述汇编了有关数字健康技术(DHTs)在新冠疫情期间支持初级卫生保健(PHC)的发展情况以及对初级卫生保健未来的经验教训。所纳入的文献发表于新冠疫情高峰期(2019 - 2021年),从PubMed、Scopus和谷歌学术搜索中检索,并在互联网上进行手工搜索。使用了预先定义的纳入标准,应用了主题分析,报告遵循范围综述的PRISMA。最终综合纳入了46项研究(40篇文章、1本书、2章书籍内容、1篇工作论文和2份技术报告)。这些研究审视了DHTs的各个方面,涉及19种DHTs以及20个应用领域,可归纳为五个更大的初级卫生保健功能:一般初级卫生保健服务提供(远程会诊、电子诊断、电子处方等);行为促进和数字健康素养(例如,应对疫苗犹豫);监测功能;疫苗接种和药物;以及加强系统决策,以便在新冠疫情期间对正在进行的初级卫生保健干预措施进行适当跟进。DHTs有潜力解决甚至在新冠疫情之前就困扰我们的一些问题。因此,本研究采用前瞻性观点,进一步推动基于证据的DHTs的使用,使其在正常情况和疫情期间更具包容性、教育性并满足人们的需求。需要开展更多研究问题更聚焦的研究,尤其要注重DHTs使用中的质量保证、技术方面(数字健康工具、基础设施和平台的标准)以及财务方面(数字健康服务的支付和采用激励措施)。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s12553-023-00725-7获取的补充材料。