Bartlett Andrew, Pace Jessica, Arora Angela, Penm Jonathan
School of Pharmacy, Faculty of Medicine and Health, The University of Sydney, Camperdown, NSW 2006, Australia.
Department of Pharmacy, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, NSW 2031, Australia.
Pharmacy (Basel). 2022 Dec 27;11(1):5. doi: 10.3390/pharmacy11010005.
Verbal communication is a vital skill for pharmacists and essential for improving patient care. The aim of this study was to explore students' perception of the impact of self-reflection and self- and peer-assessment on simulated patient counselling sessions.
Focus groups explored student perceptions of how this course and way of learning has impacted their performance at counselling patients. Data were analysed using iterative inductive thematic analysis procedures and mapped to the self-determination theory.
Nine focus groups with 47 pharmacy students. We identified three main themes and ten associated subthemes. These were learning style (sub-themes gradual introduction to assessment, learning through self-reflection videos, authentic assessment, individual learning compared to group learning, and learning through observation of best practice), feedback (sub-themes inconsistent feedback, summative feedback, perception of self and relationship with peers informing peer assessment) and benefits in real life practice. These themes mapped well to self-determination theory and highlighted that additional focus may be required for benefits in real-life practice.
Students' perceptions of self-reflection and self- and peer-assessment centred on learning style, feedback, and benefits in real-life practice. Additional focus on benefits of this unit of study in real-life practice and work integrated learning on placements may further strengthen the impact of these learning activities.
言语沟通是药剂师的一项重要技能,对改善患者护理至关重要。本研究的目的是探讨学生对自我反思、自我评估和同伴评估对模拟患者咨询环节影响的看法。
焦点小组探讨了学生对该课程及学习方式如何影响其患者咨询表现的看法。使用迭代归纳主题分析程序对数据进行分析,并映射到自我决定理论。
九个焦点小组,共47名药学专业学生。我们确定了三个主要主题和十个相关子主题。这些主题分别是学习风格(子主题包括评估的逐步引入、通过自我反思视频学习、真实评估、个体学习与小组学习的比较以及通过观察最佳实践学习)、反馈(子主题包括不一致的反馈、总结性反馈、自我认知以及与同伴的关系对同伴评估的影响)和在实际生活实践中的益处。这些主题与自我决定理论契合良好,并强调在实际生活实践中的益处可能需要更多关注。
学生对自我反思、自我评估和同伴评估的看法集中在学习风格、反馈以及在实际生活实践中的益处上。更多关注本学习单元在实际生活实践中的益处以及实习中的工作综合学习,可能会进一步增强这些学习活动的影响。