Murphy S B, Simon S R, Kijewski P K, Wilkinson R H, Griscom N T
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Children's Hospital Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts 02115.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1987 Oct;69(8):1169-76.
Biplane roentgenography, axial roentgenography, and fluoroscopy are the usual roentgenographic methods of measuring femoral anteversion. These methods use a strict geometrical definition of anteversion. The computerized tomography method of measuring anteversion that was developed recently, and is now widely used, does not adhere to the accepted definition of anteversion and has not been tested for accuracy in a large series. In the present study, the widely used computerized-tomography method of measuring anteversion was tested on thirty-two femoral specimens. With that method, anteversion was consistently underestimated by an average of 10 degrees compared with direct measurements and was reproducible only to within +/- 3.6 degrees. Therefore, a new method of measuring anteversion using computerized tomography was developed. It was shown to be accurate to +/- 1 degree, as tested on the same specimens. This study demonstrated geometrically why the currently practiced computerized-tomography method of selecting the points that are used to define the axis of the femoral neck is not consistent with geometrical definitions of anteversion. A more accurate method for both defining the axis of the femoral neck and measuring femoral anteversion is described and recommended for clinical use.
双平面X线摄影、轴向X线摄影和荧光透视是测量股骨前倾的常用X线检查方法。这些方法采用了严格的前倾几何学定义。最近开发并广泛应用的计算机断层扫描测量前倾的方法并不遵循公认的前倾定义,且尚未在大量病例中进行准确性测试。在本研究中,对32个股骨标本采用广泛应用的计算机断层扫描测量前倾的方法进行测试。采用该方法时,与直接测量相比,前倾始终平均低估10度,且仅在±3.6度范围内可重复。因此,开发了一种利用计算机断层扫描测量前倾的新方法。在相同标本上测试显示,其准确性可达±1度。本研究从几何学角度说明了为何目前采用的计算机断层扫描方法选择用于定义股骨颈轴线的点不符合前倾的几何学定义。本文描述并推荐了一种用于定义股骨颈轴线和测量股骨前倾的更准确方法以供临床使用。