Bell Institute of Health and Nutrition, General Mills, Minneapolis, MN 55427, USA.
Appetite Control and Energy Balance Research Group, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK.
Nutrients. 2023 Jan 7;15(2):304. doi: 10.3390/nu15020304.
There has been no validated digital tool for measuring appetite with a visual analog scale (VAS) through a mobile app using participants' smart phones for data collection in virtual settings. To fill the gap, we developed a digital VAS and conducted a digital cross-over clinical trial by comparing appetite responses measured by this digital tool versus paper-based VAS in 102 participants in a free-living environment. Participants consumed either a 230 or 460 kcal breakfast in randomized order in two virtual sessions, and their appetite was measured over the next 4 h using both tools. The results revealed no significant difference in hunger, fullness, satiety, or desire to eat measured by digital and paper VAS. Paper VAS resulted in a higher prospective consumption score than digital VAS; the difference (1.1 out of 100 points) was statistically significant but not practically relevant. Bland and Altman analysis also indicated consistency in the results from the two methods. In conclusion, digital VAS on a smart phone is a validated tool for appetite measurement in the real world; it provides a new way for researchers to leverage participants' mobile devices for appetite data collection in digital trials.
目前还没有经过验证的数字工具可以通过智能手机上的移动应用程序使用视觉模拟量表 (VAS) 来测量虚拟环境下参与者的食欲,我们需要填补这一空白。因此,我们开发了一种数字 VAS,并通过在 102 名参与者的自由生活环境中进行数字交叉临床试验,比较了这种数字工具与纸质 VAS 测量的食欲反应。参与者以随机顺序在两个虚拟会议中分别摄入 230 或 460 卡路里的早餐,并在接下来的 4 小时内使用这两种工具测量他们的食欲。结果显示,数字 VAS 和纸质 VAS 测量的饥饿感、饱腹感、满足感或进食欲望没有显著差异。纸质 VAS 得出的预期消费评分高于数字 VAS;这种差异(100 分中的 1.1 分)在统计学上显著,但在实际应用中并不相关。Bland 和 Altman 分析也表明两种方法的结果具有一致性。总之,智能手机上的数字 VAS 是一种经过验证的用于测量真实世界食欲的工具;它为研究人员提供了一种新的方法,可利用参与者的移动设备在数字试验中收集食欲数据。