Heckman James J, Pinto Rodrigo
Department of Economics and Center for the Economics of Human Development, University of Chicago, 1126 East 59th Street, Chicago, IL 60637.
Department of Economics, University of California Los Angeles, 8385 Bunche Hall, Los Angeles, CA 90095.
J Quant Econ. 2022 Sep;20(Suppl 1):7-30. doi: 10.1007/s40953-022-00307-w. Epub 2022 Sep 12.
Orthogonal Arrays are a powerful class of experimental designs that has been widely used to determine efficient arrangements of treatment factors in randomized controlled trials. Despite its popularity, the method is seldom used in social sciences. Social experiments must cope with randomization compromises such as noncompliance that often prevents the use of elaborate designs. We present a novel application of orthogonal designs that addresses the particular challenges arising in social experiments. We characterize the identification of counterfactual variables as a finite mixture problem in which choice incentives, rather than treatment factors, are randomly assigned. We show that the causal inference generated by an orthogonal array of incentives greatly outperforms a traditional design.
正交阵列是一类强大的实验设计,已被广泛用于确定随机对照试验中治疗因素的有效安排。尽管该方法很受欢迎,但在社会科学中很少使用。社会实验必须应对诸如不依从等随机化折衷问题,这常常阻碍复杂设计的使用。我们提出了正交设计的一种新应用,以应对社会实验中出现的特殊挑战。我们将反事实变量的识别表征为一个有限混合问题,其中选择激励而非治疗因素是随机分配的。我们表明,由激励的正交阵列产生的因果推断大大优于传统设计。