Comparative Cognition, Messerli Research Institute, University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Medical University of Vienna and University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
HAS University of Applied Sciences, 's-Hertogenbosch, The Netherlands.
Proc Biol Sci. 2023 Jan 25;290(1991):20221621. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2022.1621.
The extent to which dogs () as a domesticated species understand human intentions is still a matter of debate. The unwilling-unable paradigm has been developed to examine whether nonhuman animals are sensitive to intentions underlying human actions. In this paradigm, subjects tended to wait longer in the testing area when presented with a human that appeared willing but unable to transfer food to them compared to an unwilling (teasing) human. In the present study, we conducted the unwilling-unable paradigm with dogs using a detailed behavioural analysis based on machine-learning driven three-dimensional tracking. Throughout two preregistered experiments, we found evidence, in line with our prediction, that dogs reacted more impatiently to actions signalling unwillingness to transfer food rather than inability. These differences were consistent through two different samples of pet dogs (total = 96) and they were evident also in the machine-learning generated three-dimensional tracking data. Our results therefore provide robust evidence that dogs distinguish between similar actions (leading to the same outcome) associated with different intentions. However, their reactions did not lead to any measurable preference for one experimenter over the other in a subsequent transfer phase. We discuss different cognitive mechanisms that might underlie dogs' performance in this paradigm.
狗作为一个被驯化的物种在多大程度上理解人类的意图,这仍然是一个争论的问题。不愿意-不能范式已经被开发出来,以检验非人类动物是否对人类行为背后的意图敏感。在这个范式中,当呈现一个看起来愿意但不能将食物转移给它们的人类时,与不愿意(戏弄)的人类相比,受试狗在测试区域等待的时间更长。在本研究中,我们使用基于机器学习驱动的三维跟踪的详细行为分析,对狗进行了不愿意-不能范式。在两个预先注册的实验中,我们发现了与我们的预测一致的证据,即狗对表示不愿意转移食物而不是不能的动作反应更不耐烦。这些差异在两个不同的宠物狗样本(总计 = 96)中是一致的,在机器学习生成的三维跟踪数据中也是明显的。因此,我们的研究结果提供了有力的证据,证明狗能够区分与不同意图相关的类似动作(导致相同的结果)。然而,在随后的转移阶段,它们的反应并没有导致对任何一个实验者的任何可衡量的偏好。我们讨论了不同的认知机制,这些机制可能是狗在这个范式中表现的基础。
Sci Rep. 2021-9-1
Anim Cogn. 2014-1-5
Imaging Neurosci (Camb). 2024-12-11
Front Psychol. 2025-6-25
Learn Behav. 2025-6
Front Vet Sci. 2024-6-14
Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2024-7
Biol Lett. 2024-1
Sci Rep. 2021-9-1
Proc Biol Sci. 2021-7-28
J Comp Psychol. 2015-11
PLoS One. 2014-9-17