Catala Amélie, Mang Britta, Wallis Lisa, Huber Ludwig
Comparative Cognition, Messerli Research Institute, University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Medical University of Vienna, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Anim Cogn. 2017 Jul;20(4):581-589. doi: 10.1007/s10071-017-1082-x. Epub 2017 Mar 24.
Currently, there is still no consensus about whether animals can ascribe mental states (Theory of Mind) to themselves and others. Showing animals can respond to cues that indicate whether another has visual access to a target or not, and that they are able to use this information as a basis for whom to rely on as an informant, is an important step forward in this direction. Domestic dogs (Canis familiaris) with human informants are an ideal model, because they show high sensitivity towards human eye contact, they have proven able to assess the attentional state of humans in food-stealing or food-begging contexts, and they follow human gaze behind a barrier when searching for food. With 16 dogs, we not only replicated the main results of Maginnity and Grace (Anim Cogn 17(6):1375-1392, 2014) who recently found that dogs preferred to follow the pointing of a human who witnessed a food hiding event over a human who did not (the Guesser-Knower task), but also extended this finding with a further, critical control for behaviour-reading: two informants showed identical looking behaviour, but due to their different position in the room, only one had the opportunity to see where the food was hidden by a third person. Preference for the Knower in this critical test provides solid evidence for geometrical gaze following and perspective taking in dogs.
目前,关于动物是否能将心理状态(心理理论)归因于自身和其他个体,仍未达成共识。证明动物能够对表明其他个体是否能看到目标的线索做出反应,并且它们能够利用这些信息作为选择可靠信息源的依据,是朝这个方向迈出的重要一步。有人类信息提供者的家犬(犬属家犬)是一个理想的模型,因为它们对人类眼神接触表现出高度敏感性,已被证明能够在偷食或乞讨食物的情境中评估人类的注意力状态,并且在寻找食物时会在障碍物后跟随人类的目光。我们用16只狗进行实验,不仅重复了马金尼蒂和格雷斯(《动物认知》,2014年,第17卷第6期:1375 - 1392页)最近的主要研究结果,即狗更倾向于跟随目睹食物隐藏事件的人的指示,而不是没有目睹的人(猜测者 - 知晓者任务),而且通过进一步对行为解读的关键控制扩展了这一发现:两名信息提供者表现出相同的注视行为,但由于他们在房间中的位置不同,只有一人有机会看到食物被第三人藏在哪里。在这个关键测试中对知晓者的偏好为狗的几何注视跟随和观点采择提供了确凿证据。