Sonesson B, Ljunggren B, Säveland H, Brandt L
Department of Psychiatry, University Hospital, Lund, Sweden.
Neurosurgery. 1987 Sep;21(3):279-87. doi: 10.1227/00006123-198709000-00001.
Does early aneurysm operation, while lowering the overall management mortality, result in an unacceptable morbidity in terms of increased cognitive disturbances and psychosocial maladjustment? The present study evaluates quality of life, degree of cognitive dysfunction, and adjustment of 93 patients with satisfactory neurological recoveries after operations for ruptured supratentorial aneurysms. All patients had been in neurological Grades I to III (Hunt and Hess) after subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH). Fifty-five patients were operated upon during the acute state, i.e., within 72 hours after bleeding (early surgery = ES), and 38 patients had been subjected to late surgery (LS), i.e., were operated on 9 days or more after SAH. Each patient was subjected to a clinical interview and a comprehensive neuropsychological investigation. The time interval between SAH and assessment varied between 12 and 103 months (mean, 56 months). The results confirm that there are indication of cognitive malfunctioning and psychosocial disturbances of varying severity and distribution in patients who have undergone LS. The pattern and distribution of sequelae after LS did not differ substantially from that in patients subjected to ES. The results offer strong support to the concept that remaining disturbances in cognition are mainly related to the impact of the initial hemorrhage per se. In patients with anterior communicating artery aneurysms, a larger decrease in tempo and perceptual vigilance was noted, suggesting that the subfrontal midline structures are particularly involved in processes demanding flexibility, attention, and capacity to adapt to novel demands in a perceptual situation.
早期动脉瘤手术在降低总体治疗死亡率的同时,是否会因认知障碍增加和心理社会适应不良而导致不可接受的发病率?本研究评估了93例幕上破裂动脉瘤手术后神经功能恢复良好的患者的生活质量、认知功能障碍程度和适应情况。所有患者蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)后神经功能分级均为Ⅰ至Ⅲ级(Hunt和Hess分级)。55例患者在急性期即出血后72小时内接受手术(早期手术=ES),38例患者接受晚期手术(LS),即SAH后9天或更晚接受手术。对每位患者进行了临床访谈和全面的神经心理学调查。SAH与评估之间的时间间隔在12至103个月之间(平均56个月)。结果证实,接受LS的患者存在不同严重程度和分布的认知功能障碍和心理社会障碍迹象。LS后后遗症的模式和分布与接受ES的患者没有实质性差异。结果有力支持了以下观点:认知方面的持续障碍主要与初始出血本身的影响有关。在前交通动脉瘤患者中,观察到节奏和感知警觉性有更大程度的下降,这表明额下中线结构特别参与了在感知情境中需要灵活性、注意力和适应新需求能力的过程。