Powell J, Kitchen N, Heslin J, Greenwood R
Department of Psychology, Goldsmiths College, New Cross, London, UK.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2004 Aug;75(8):1119-24. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.2002.000414.
To evaluate functioning, 18 months after surgery, of 49 patients with good neurological recovery following aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH), and to determine the extent of any improvements in disturbances of mood, cognitive functioning, and levels of activity and participation previously observed at 9 month follow up.
SAH patients, matched for age, gender, and occupation with healthy control participants, completely quantitative measures of mood (HADS, FIES, BDI) and activity/participation (BICRO-39 scales), and a brief cognitive assessment battery (verbal fluency, digit span, prose recall). Controls completed the HADS and the BICRO-39.
Patients showed some recovery of cognitive functioning, though impairments of prose recall persisted. Anxiety and depression symptoms were higher in patients than in controls, but fewer than 20% scored in the clinical range on any questionnaires except for RIES-Intrusive thoughts (22%); only three showed signs of full blown post-traumatic stress disorder. Almost half showed elevated dependence on others for domestic activities and organisation and abnormally low levels of employment. Very little variance in outcome was predicted by demographic variables, neurological or cognitive impairment, prior life stress, or mood. However, levels of social activity and self-organisation were related to persisting fatigue.
The observed decline in intrusive thoughts and avoidance over time is consistent with that seen after life threatening illness or trauma. The persistent reductions in independence and levels of employment may in some cases reflect considered lifestyle adjustments rather than adverse and unwanted changes but in others indicate a need for focused rehabilitation.
评估49例动脉瘤性蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)后神经功能恢复良好的患者术后18个月的功能状况,并确定在9个月随访时观察到的情绪、认知功能、活动水平和参与度障碍的改善程度。
将SAH患者与健康对照者按年龄、性别和职业进行匹配,采用完全定量的情绪测量方法(医院焦虑抑郁量表、功能独立性评定量表、贝克抑郁量表)和活动/参与度测量方法(BICRO-39量表),以及简短的认知评估量表(语言流畅性、数字广度、散文回忆)。对照组完成医院焦虑抑郁量表和BICRO-39量表。
患者的认知功能有一定恢复,但散文回忆能力仍有损害。患者的焦虑和抑郁症状高于对照组,但除RIES-侵入性思维量表(22%)外,在任何问卷中得分在临床范围内的患者均少于20%;只有3例表现出完全性创伤后应激障碍的迹象。几乎一半的患者在家庭活动和组织方面表现出对他人的高度依赖,就业水平异常低。人口统计学变量、神经或认知损害、既往生活压力或情绪对结果的预测差异很小。然而,社交活动水平和自我组织能力与持续疲劳有关。
随着时间的推移,观察到的侵入性思维和回避行为的减少与危及生命的疾病或创伤后的情况一致。独立性和就业水平的持续下降在某些情况下可能反映了深思熟虑后的生活方式调整,而非不利和不必要的变化,但在另一些情况下则表明需要针对性的康复治疗。