Acuña Josie, Pacheco Garrett, Yarnish Adrienne A, Andrade Javier, Haight Stephen, Coe Ian, Carter Jeremy, Adhikari Srikar
Emergency Medicine, University of Arizona College of Medicine, Tucson, USA.
Emergency Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, Fresno, USA.
Cureus. 2022 Dec 27;14(12):e33003. doi: 10.7759/cureus.33003. eCollection 2022 Dec.
Objectives The objective of this study is to describe a simple, replicable method to create neck models for the purpose of education and practice of ultrasound (US) identification of anatomic landmarks for cricothyrotomy. The second objective is to assess the model's capability in training emergency medicine (EM) residents in the US identification of anatomic landmarks for cricothyrotomy. Methods This is a cross-sectional study using a convenience sample of EM residents. Participants were taught to identify the thyroid cartilage, the cricothyroid membrane (CTM), and the cricoid cartilage using US. After an instructional period, participants performed a US examination on gel models designed to overly a live, human neck simulating various scenarios: thin neck, thick neck, anterior neck hematoma, and subcutaneous emphysema. Residents were asked to identify the thyroid cartilage, the CTM, and the cricoid cartilage as quickly as possible. The mean time to successful identification was reported in seconds. Following the scanning session, participants were asked to complete a post-survey. After the session, the video recordings were reviewed by an emergency US fellowship-trained physician to assess the visuomotor skills of each participant. Results A total of 42 residents participated in the study. Ninety-three percent (32/42; 95% CI 80.3% - 98.2%) of residents were able to obtain an optimal sagittal or parasagittal sonographic view of the anterior airway landmarks. Of these residents, 21.4% (9/42; 95% CI 11.5% - 36.2%) required minimal assistance with the initial probe placement. The visuomotor scores were recorded for each participant. Results of the pearson correlation indicated that there was a significant positive relationship between the residents' year in training with their visuomotor score (r(40) = .41, p = .007). When scanning the thin neck, 90.5% (38/42; 95% CI 77.4% - 96.8%) of residents were able to successfully identify the landmarks. The median time to completion was 27 seconds. When scanning the subcutaneous air model, 88.1% (37/42; 95% CI 74.5% - 95.3%) of residents were able to successfully identify the landmarks. The median time to completion was 26 seconds. When scanning the neck with the fluid collection 95.2% (40/42; 95% CI 83.4% - 99.5%) of residents were able to successfully identify the landmarks with a median time of 20 seconds for identification. When scanning the thick neck model, 73.8% (31/42; 95% CI 58.8% - 84.8%) of residents were able to successfully identify the landmarks taking a median time of 26 seconds. After the training session, 76.2% of residents reported that they felt either "confident" or "extremely confident" in identifying the CTM using US. Conclusion The novel anterior neck gel models used in this study were found to be adequate for training EM residents in the US identification of anterior neck anatomy. Residents were successfully trained in identifying the important anterior neck landmarks that are useful when predicting a difficult anterior airway and planning for surgical cricothyrotomy. Residents overall felt that the models simulated the appropriate anatomic scenarios. The majority felt confident in identifying the CTM using US.
目的 本研究的目的是描述一种简单、可重复的方法来创建颈部模型,用于超声(US)识别环甲膜切开术解剖标志的教育和实践。第二个目的是评估该模型在培训急诊医学(EM)住院医师进行US识别环甲膜切开术解剖标志方面的能力。方法 这是一项横断面研究,使用EM住院医师的便利样本。参与者学习使用US识别甲状腺软骨、环甲膜(CTM)和环状软骨。在一段教学期后,参与者对设计用于模拟各种情况的凝胶模型进行US检查:细颈、粗颈、前颈部血肿和皮下气肿。要求住院医师尽快识别甲状腺软骨、CTM和环状软骨。成功识别的平均时间以秒为单位报告。扫描 session 后,要求参与者完成一份调查。 session 后,由接受过急诊US fellowship培训的医生审查视频记录,以评估每个参与者的视觉运动技能。结果 共有42名住院医师参与了研究。93%(32/42;95%CI 80.3% - 98.2%)的住院医师能够获得前气道标志的最佳矢状或旁矢状超声视图。在这些住院医师中,21.4%(9/42;95%CI 11.5% - 36.2%)在初始探头放置时需要最少的帮助。记录了每个参与者的视觉运动分数。Pearson相关性结果表明,住院医师的培训年份与其视觉运动分数之间存在显著正相关(r(40) =.41,p =.007)。扫描细颈时,90.5%(38/42;95%CI 77.4% - 96.8%)的住院医师能够成功识别标志。完成的中位时间为27秒。扫描皮下气模型时,88.1%(37/42;95%CI 74.5% - 95.3%)的住院医师能够成功识别标志。完成的中位时间为26秒。扫描有液体聚集的颈部时,95.2%(40/42;95%CI 83.4% - 99.5%)的住院医师能够成功识别标志,识别的中位时间为20秒。扫描粗颈模型时,73.8%(31/42;95%CI 58.8% - 84.8%)的住院医师能够成功识别标志,中位时间为26秒。培训 session 后,76.2%的住院医师报告说他们在使用US识别CTM时感到“自信”或“极其自信”。结论 本研究中使用的新型前颈部凝胶模型被发现足以培训EM住院医师进行US识别前颈部解剖结构。住院医师在识别预测困难前气道和计划手术环甲膜切开术时有用的重要前颈部标志方面得到了成功培训。住院医师总体上认为这些模型模拟了适当的解剖场景。大多数人对使用US识别CTM感到自信。