Kathane Prachi J, Tripathi Mahesh A, Tiwari Sudhanshu Shekher
School of Forensic Science and Risk Management, Rashtriya Raksha University, Gujarat, India.
Indian J Psychiatry. 2022 Nov-Dec;64(6):540-544. doi: 10.4103/indianjpsychiatry.indianjpsychiatry_390_21. Epub 2022 Nov 30.
There is limited research in India focusing on the criminal justice system issues involving a special category of victims and accused suffering from unsoundness of mind. According to the Mental Health Care Act, 2017, they need immediate mental health services, as denial of the same is a violation of their fundamental right. Despite several advancements, people with unsound mind serving their sentences in the prisons constitute a major lot of the total prison population in India, despite the fact that they are the most helpless targets of human rights violations. Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code provides a constitutional right to an accused with unsound mind to seek defense against prosecution; but due to lack of awareness and acceptance and also due to outdated testing methods, the law is not under frequent practice and not exercised to its complete worth. By compromising on the procedure established by law, they are kept under trial in judicial custody. Thus, there is an urgent need to identify and address such victims and provide them with right care and protection that the constitution entitles them. This review article is an attempt to explore and highlight this issue, to raise a voice for identification of such violations, to provide means to deliberate medicolegal aid, and lastly to find out probable solutions, recommendations, and suggestions for a better administration of justice by providing legal security to the protection of basic human rights of people with an unsound mind.
在印度,针对涉及患有精神疾病的特殊类别受害者和被告的刑事司法系统问题的研究有限。根据2017年《精神卫生保健法》,他们需要立即获得精神卫生服务,因为拒绝提供此类服务侵犯了他们的基本权利。尽管有多项进展,但在监狱服刑的精神不健全者在印度监狱总人数中占了很大比例,尽管事实上他们是最无助的人权侵犯受害者。《印度刑法典》第84条赋予精神不健全的被告寻求免于起诉辩护的宪法权利;但由于缺乏认识和接受,以及测试方法过时,该法律并未经常实施,也未充分发挥其价值。由于在法定程序上打折扣,他们被司法拘留在审判中。因此,迫切需要识别并处理这类受害者,并为他们提供他们提供宪法赋予他们的适当照顾和保护。这篇综述文章试图探讨并突出这一问题,为识别此类侵权行为发声,提供商讨医疗法律援助的方法,最后通过为保护精神不健全者的基本人权提供法律保障,找出可能的解决方案、建议,以更好地实现司法公正。